Salartarium (talk | contribs) m →Mrbah Chieve: judging |
m Add <nowiki> to block incorrect links. |
||
| (22 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown) | |||
| Line 30: | Line 30: | ||
** [[User:Drebin 679]] | ** [[User:Drebin 679]] | ||
* Event's Patron - gives prize recommendations and evaluates an editor's excellence (see [[#Judging process]]) | * Event's Patron - gives prize recommendations and evaluates an editor's excellence (see [[#Judging process]]) | ||
** [[User:Turlough Dominian]] | ** [[User:Turlough Dominian]] | ||
** [[User:Chanstaner vi Adraille]] | ** [[User:Chanstaner vi Adraille]] | ||
===Restrictions and exclusions=== | ===Restrictions and exclusions=== | ||
| Line 197: | Line 194: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - EVEmon page cleanup, good edit summaries, categorization. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, EVEmon page and project, Homefront project. | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Yes. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - Yes. | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with many. | |||
* Edit summaries? - Good. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 209: | Line 213: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
A nice cleanup of the EVEMon page, though IMO I think the change of the character setup page from a numbered list to just a paragraph is a bit of a regression. | |||
Merging the Uni medals and ribbons pages was a big lift. Don't know I fully agree with it at first taste, but I must acknowledge the accurate edit summaries and that it was, again, a big lift. Later edits did have Discord correspondence from Amfion, with nice details. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 224: | Line 225: | ||
Updated EVEMon page based on an clean-up tag. Requested review and feedback of edit on discord. Very descriptive edit summary. | Updated EVEMon page based on an clean-up tag. Requested review and feedback of edit on discord. Very descriptive edit summary. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 296: | Line 292: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Fits that can be imported. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA | |||
* User Namespace? - Used. | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Yes. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 307: | Line 310: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
A good maintenance edit of the old NSC page. Fittings I do have to agree with Turtle about the EFTs not being copypastable ingame (I went and fixed that). | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 321: | Line 319: | ||
Good use of user namespace but most edit summaries were non descriptive. Reorganised Null-Sec Campus page and added new example fits in scanner alts page. | Good use of user namespace but most edit summaries were non descriptive. Reorganised Null-Sec Campus page and added new example fits in scanner alts page. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 981: | Line 974: | ||
| [https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/index.php?pageid=22778&diff=213534 User:Boundbylife] | | [https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/index.php?pageid=22778&diff=213534 User:Boundbylife] | ||
| 2024-03-08 12:08:40 | | 2024-03-08 12:08:40 | ||
| Created page with "{{t|#ask: [[:Category:E-Uni Services]]|format=flatlist|sep= * }} [[:Category:E-Uni Services]]" | | Created page with <nowiki>"{{t|#ask: [[:Category:E-Uni Services]]|format=flatlist|sep= * }} [[:Category:E-Uni Services]]"</nowiki> | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/index.php?pageid=2644&diff=213507 Fitting missile launchers] | | [https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/index.php?pageid=2644&diff=213507 Fitting missile launchers] | ||
| Line 1,037: | Line 1,030: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Many excellent edits. | |||
* Judges in favor of the editor recieving an Excellence prize. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Yes. | |||
* User Namespace? - Used. | |||
* Template? - Created. | |||
* Style and ideals? - Yes. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - Yes. | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes. | |||
* Edit summaries? - Excellent. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,057: | Line 1,058: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Concur with other judges. Going to cop Evon's summary and label this my {{Co|yellow|Excellence candidate}} as well. | |||
The services template that Boundbylife created is quite simple. But it fills a need that was not being addressed by anything else before. And with a push now to put all services on the wiki instead of a hodgepodge of wiki, forum, and "trust me bro, this program exists". It's been fanned out to a variety of services already, which speaks to the need being there for this template. For that alone I'm willing to give that my recommendation. | |||
Transclusion though I'm a bit iffy on. Those tend to not survive well if the transcluded page later gets restructured. Didn't happen during the contest period though, so no worries! | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,068: | Line 1,068: | ||
way to many edits for any sane person to go over fully but the random ones i did look at seemed ok and imrpoved the apearance along the way some miner edits also | way to many edits for any sane person to go over fully but the random ones i did look at seemed ok and imrpoved the apearance along the way some miner edits also | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 1,100: | Line 1,091: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Added a fresh perspective to a page. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - NA | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,111: | Line 1,109: | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Page is now well polished. A good first edit that puts down what is common knowledge for veteran players, but might be surprising for new players.| width= 100%|}} | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Page is now well polished. A good first edit that puts down what is common knowledge for veteran players, but might be surprising for new players.| width= 100%|}} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
I heard a take that the real value in a ship encylopedia, as it were, is not the raw stats of things (you can get that in-game, of course), but in those somewhat subjective yet collectively agreeable takes on what skills and tactics are good for a given ship. Given that the UniWiki lacks that for many ships, an edit that adds on to that is generally a good thing, so I appreciate the edit. | |||
Using the utility highs of a Dragoon to salvage while ratting is something worth noting, as most other ships in its class would have to sacrifice something in order to do the same. Would want to see the comparison to the Algos though, as it has the same amount of high slots and could fit itself the same way as the hypothetical Dragoon fit (despite having five turret hardpoints). | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,124: | Line 1,119: | ||
Minor edit highlighting the salvaging capability of Dragoon in PVE, however non descriptive edit summary. | Minor edit highlighting the salvaging capability of Dragoon in PVE, however non descriptive edit summary. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 1,176: | Line 1,166: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Good edit summaries, updated contract page. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, updated contract page. | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - NA | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - Yes, contacted Drebin. | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes. | |||
* Edit summaries? - Good. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,190: | Line 1,187: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Full disclosure: I did help Clio out with some image version removals. | |||
From that experience though, I can say that they demonstrated excellence in bouncing off of other wiki editors and contacting staff for help when needed. The content that was edited was small compared to some others who took part, but the Discord communication combined with the edit summaries does make me want to lean that way. If judging on the amount of work done, others would probably be more qualified for obvious reasons. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,203: | Line 1,197: | ||
Informative edit including 3 image file updates. Overly descriptive edit summary. Asked help on discord about file deletion process on wiki. | Informative edit including 3 image file updates. Overly descriptive edit summary. Asked help on discord about file deletion process on wiki. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 1,255: | Line 1,244: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Communication, updated a guide. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Yes, updated a guide. | |||
* User Namespace? - Used. | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - NA | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with many. | |||
* Edit summaries? - Good. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,269: | Line 1,265: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
I'm not an explo guy, so I can't judge the veracity of the Sleeper Cache page changes. I can say, though, that they did chat on the wiki channel in the E-UNI Discord extensively while making these edits, as Chanstaner said. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,282: | Line 1,273: | ||
Small informative update, which was extensively discussed on forum and discord. Use of user namespace, with mix of descriptive and non descriptive edit summaries. | Small informative update, which was extensively discussed on forum and discord. Use of user namespace, with mix of descriptive and non descriptive edit summaries. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 1,310: | Line 1,296: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Proofreading. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - NA | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - Yes, extensive edit. | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Good. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,323: | Line 1,316: | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Conciseness is important for long wiki articles and upholds the MoS on Words to Watch. Britain shall become Airstrip One| width= 100%|}} | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Conciseness is important for long wiki articles and upholds the MoS on Words to Watch. Britain shall become Airstrip One| width= 100%|}} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Yeah, short of a couple of typos ("missiles" in RLML, "traveling") and a style change, I don't know if I agree with the others for the reasons Evon mentioned. It is good that people are willing to patrol these big pages that we have around and put fixes when they see something they don't think is right, so I appreciate the edit in its entirety regardless. Concur on descriptive and effective use of edit summary. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,336: | Line 1,324: | ||
Spelling correction and proofreading of a long wiki page. Edit summary is informative. | Spelling correction and proofreading of a long wiki page. Edit summary is informative. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 1,500: | Line 1,483: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Great cooperation, use of Draft Namespace, | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA | |||
* User Namespace? - Yes, Halsky's. | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Yes. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with many. | |||
* Edit summaries? - NA | |||
Chris Halsky's comments: | |||
* Just to clarify - initial edits to "Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace" were done in my User space, as we didn't want to break the main page while we sorted out Tabs and stuff. It was later copied as a whole to proper space - without Dossoles' work we would not be able to. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,514: | Line 1,507: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Disclosure: I did poke Dossoles to remind him to put "BEAUTIFY" in one of his edits during the contest period. | |||
Lot of good edits into a userspace page repository on Abyssals. Dossoles is very active on Discord and discussed the things he edited here, but there wasn't much in terms of edit summaries. Also, imaginary points do probably have to be reserved because most of the edits did not take place or manifest into the main namespace. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Lots of little additions nothing jumped out at me negativly , overall not bad and i do like reading a wiki page where the layout doesn't magically change for no reason so good imo | Lots of little additions nothing jumped out at me negativly , overall not bad and i do like reading a wiki page where the layout doesn't magically change for no reason so good imo | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 1,588: | Line 1,569: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Mix of edits, excellent edit summaries. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, typos. | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Yes. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Excellent. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,598: | Line 1,586: | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|I like the mix of edits for this user. Combination of basic typo and formatting fixes along with sprinkling in game knowledge. Shows that new editors can quickly start contributing good work to the wiki, especially in areas longstanding editors are unfamiliar with. Followed MoS and I hope they continue to contribute after this event. |width= 100%|}} | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|I like the mix of edits for this user. Combination of basic typo and formatting fixes along with sprinkling in game knowledge. Shows that new editors can quickly start contributing good work to the wiki, especially in areas longstanding editors are unfamiliar with. Followed MoS and I hope they continue to contribute after this event. |width= 100%|}} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Good maintenance work on the new ship pages to make sure that they are formatted properly and are a little less barebones. Edit summaries are concise and to the point. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,609: | Line 1,592: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Small informational edits about suppression mechanics in FW and summaries for Guristas Pirates ships. Brief but descriptive edit summaries. | |||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 1,732: | Line 1,709: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Fewer granular edits, use of Draft Namespace, documented events, good edit summaries. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, events. | |||
* User Namespace? - Used. | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Yes. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - Yes, events. | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes. | |||
* Edit summaries? - Good. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,745: | Line 1,729: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
A very nice expansion of the Uni Fight Club page. Given the attention that the Uni gives this longstanding event, a better page for it is much appreciated. | |||
I agree with Chanstaner's points on the edit quantity relative to the changes. No Discord or talk page activity to note (Elan maintained the page near single-handedly for a couple of years, so it makes sense). | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,758: | Line 1,739: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Comprehensive rework of the Fight Club page with a lot of new information, which may be useful to new hosts and participants. Too many minor edits for updating few words, but with descriptive edit summaries. | |||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 1,793: | Line 1,768: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Content that can be expanded in the future. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - NA | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Ok. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,806: | Line 1,788: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Ooh. Pages like the one added on the [[Arithmos Tyrannos]] makes me *wish* we had an EVElopedia or EVEMon-style data dump of all the items in this place. Which I guess begs the question "Why not just use EVERef"? And I guess my answer is that while that's just a data dump, a wiki offers the potential to have both a data dump and some contextual information to better massage that raw data in the context of the things surrounding it. | |||
Like with someone adding a [[Gecko]] page, though, we already struggle just keeping what we currently have up to date, and don't have the templates currently to properly support things like drones or specific rats yet. Adding literally tens of thousands of items would be a disaster maintenance-wise given our current plight. | |||
Oh, uh, anyways, the contest. Content was sturctured fine. Some icon pizzazz and integration with other pages could be added, but again, the Wiki currently operates with expectation that there isn't a data dump item ID repository available. So to have that integrated for some rats but not others would be odd. And here I go again about the greater Wiki... | |||
Lacking a summary for a page creation is understandable. No out-of-wiki communications that I am aware of. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,819: | Line 1,802: | ||
Created new page with good information. Could be improved with some links and refrences. | Created new page with good information. Could be improved with some links and refrences. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 1,919: | Line 1,897: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Images, good edit summaries, if only the WHC bookmarking graphic was added to the Wiki. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Yes, new images. | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Yes. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - Yes, lots of icons. | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Good. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,931: | Line 1,916: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
So, I will say that Gabriel did put out a very nice infographic of the WHC's bookmarking scheme on Discord. If that had been added to the Wiki during the contest period, I'd say that he would have ''easily'' have been an excellence candidate, in my mind. | |||
But it wasn't. So going off of what was added during the contest period, having the probe window icons is a very nice addition! A cool thing to see! Edit summary was concise. No wiki-related communication I could immediately find. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 1,942: | Line 1,924: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Useful addition of new icons for the Probe Scanner window. Edit summaries are informative. | |||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 2,085: | Line 2,061: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - , images, more use of Draft Namespace. | |||
* Judges in favor of the editor recieving an Excellence prize. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, page overhaul. | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Yes. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - Yes, overhaul. | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Good. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* Article overhaul | |||
* Update and new images | |||
* Use of Edit summary | |||
* Could have used User space draft | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,096: | Line 2,084: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Some good edits here. The additional images in particular are much appreciated. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
good improvements, added suitable sized images, restructred the layour like setup overview is now b4 things like shortcuts and there was a bunch of not needed text at the start thats been moved away , all in all good improvements | good improvements, added suitable sized images, restructred the layour like setup overview is now b4 things like shortcuts and there was a bunch of not needed text at the start thats been moved away , all in all good improvements | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 2,138: | Line 2,112: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - More effort and results. | |||
* Judges objected to the editor recieving a prize. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - NA | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - NA | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,148: | Line 2,130: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Nothing more to add. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,161: | Line 2,138: | ||
Minor cleanup edit with descriptive edit summary. | Minor cleanup edit with descriptive edit summary. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 2,237: | Line 2,209: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Excellent summaries, previous implementation. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, updated info. | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Yes. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Excellent. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,249: | Line 2,228: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Good maintenance edits. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,262: | Line 2,236: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Various small edits for updating outdated information and images. Very descriptive edit summaries. | |||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 2,721: | Line 2,689: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Demonstrated excellence many times in multiple categories. | |||
* Judges in favor of the editor recieving an Excellence prize. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Took up a Project. | |||
* User Namespace? - Used. | |||
* Template? - Yes. | |||
* Style and ideals? - Yes. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - Yes. | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with many. | |||
* Edit summaries? - Excellent. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,742: | Line 2,718: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Lot of good maintenance edits. The kind of attention to our wide breadth of pages that we could most certainly use. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Dang thats alot of edits, im not going threw all that can i just say good job and ty for all your edits :D | Dang thats alot of edits, im not going threw all that can i just say good job and ty for all your edits :D | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 2,784: | Line 2,746: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Excellent style, a different implementation. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Excellent. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - Yes. | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with Vatrin. | |||
* Edit summaries? - Good. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,796: | Line 2,765: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
I have nothing to add to what the other judges have already said. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,809: | Line 2,773: | ||
Small but informative and beautiful edit. Edit and edit summary inspired by the update banner. | Small but informative and beautiful edit. Edit and edit summary inspired by the update banner. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 2,849: | Line 2,808: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Used of templates, cooperated, great edit summaries, | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Update from To-Do list. | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - Used. | |||
* Style and ideals? - Followed. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes, async, using banner. | |||
* Edit summaries? - Great. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,865: | Line 2,831: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Good maintenance edits. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
indeed its improved i did like the addition of the misstion breif | indeed its improved i did like the addition of the misstion breif | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 2,927: | Line 2,879: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Attended Wiki class, excellent style. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Major knowledge addition. | |||
* User Namespace? - Used. | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Excellent. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with Halsky. | |||
* Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,938: | Line 2,897: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Used user spaces, added to major initiative | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Disclaimer: I know Panacke through Incursions, so I might be biased. | |||
Pancake appears to have been working with the Uni's abyss study group in updating the known rat spawns. I can also say that he attended the Intro to Wiki Editing class during the teach-a-thon, so he is most definitely engaged. Edit summaries could use some work though. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,953: | Line 2,908: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Updated and beautified the page with tabs and add some new information. Brief and non descriptive edit summaries. | |||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 2,984: | Line 2,933: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Too minor, but in the spirit of the Wiki. | |||
* Judges objected to the editor recieving a prize. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - NA | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Used. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 2,993: | Line 2,950: | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Somewhat useful information. Has become a standard bit of info for these sites so the edit shows familiarity with the wiki. A great approach to adding info is looking at what others have done. | width= 100%|}} | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Somewhat useful information. Has become a standard bit of info for these sites so the edit shows familiarity with the wiki. A great approach to adding info is looking at what others have done. | width= 100%|}} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
A small but important bit of information. Always good to see these one-off edits of people just making a change that they feel is worth doing. Content wise it's not big, obviously. But small things do add up! :) | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 3,006: | Line 2,958: | ||
Minor informative edit with descriptive edit summary. | Minor informative edit with descriptive edit summary. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 3,082: | Line 3,029: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Excellent edit summaries, categorization. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Yes. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - Yes. | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - Good. | |||
* Edit summaries? - Excellent. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 3,091: | Line 3,045: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Used best practices. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Lot of edits, though as far as the main namespace goes it looks like the only changes were to the streaming guide, the Short Skill Plan, and the Flight Deck. Some good maintenance edits to all nevertheless. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 3,106: | Line 3,054: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Updated Uni flight deck location and ships. Very descriptive edit summaries. | |||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 3,169: | Line 3,111: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Good summaries. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Proofreading. | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - In the spirit. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Good. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 3,178: | Line 3,127: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Used edit summaries. Both updated information and extensively reviewed old. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Very good styling edits on a breadth of pages. From a cursory look, I couldn't find anything I strongly disagreed with. Edit summaries were succinct and accurate. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
nice little edits here and there | nice little edits here and there | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 3,224: | Line 3,158: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - In the spirit, less copy and pasting. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - NA | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 3,235: | Line 3,176: | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Very creative writing style| width= 100%|}} | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Very creative writing style| width= 100%|}} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Added descriptions to battlecruisers that didn't have them. I don't know about the RP-style writing of them, given that the other ships don't have summaries with that sort of angle. But greatly appreciate the spirit of it. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 3,248: | Line 3,184: | ||
Minor informative edit. Text was copied from other pages without change or paraphrasing to suite the topic. Edit summary could be more descriptive. | Minor informative edit. Text was copied from other pages without change or paraphrasing to suite the topic. Edit summary could be more descriptive. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 3,280: | Line 3,211: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Attended Wiki class, used Update Templated. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Tagged content that needs an update. | |||
* User Namespace? - Added personal page. | |||
* Template? - Used. | |||
* Style and ideals? - NA | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - NA | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 3,294: | Line 3,232: | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Using the update template is a good way for new players to contribute. Flagging old content helps alert other editors and ensure readers don't rely on the wrong information. Creating a user page is important for participating in the wiki.| width= 100%|}} | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Using the update template is a good way for new players to contribute. Flagging old content helps alert other editors and ensure readers don't rely on the wrong information. Creating a user page is important for participating in the wiki.| width= 100%|}} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
Tomlin was another person who attended the Intro to Wiki Editing event. One of the things I mentioned in that class was that even if you weren't sure how to fix something, just flagging it with an update template was good in order to flag whatever you think is an issue as an issue, and that someone else might be able to get to it. And going down these names in alphabetical order, I'm getting a story in reverse, how an update request from Vatrin got Monsignor to add that safety column. Very nice story, that. | |||
Aside from the class, I'm not sure if Tomlin has done any other wiki-related communications offsite. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 3,307: | Line 3,242: | ||
Minor edit. Used update template with reason but non descriptive edit summary. | Minor edit. Used update template with reason but non descriptive edit summary. | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
| Line 3,531: | Line 3,461: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Arin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
* What did Judges' value? - Gecko, no need for template, improved pages, good spirit, fewer granular edits. | |||
* Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Multiple To-Dos. | |||
* User Namespace? - NA | |||
* Template? - NA | |||
* Style and ideals? - Good path. | |||
* Confidence and deferment? - High. | |||
* Communication and cooperation? - NA | |||
* Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 3,547: | Line 3,484: | ||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|width= 100%| | ||
'''''Excellence'''' Lots of high-quality edits. Added extensive esoteric knowledge that would likely escape a player even if they played the game for decades. Was bold in adding page for the gecko. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | ||
In my last batch of comments, I had a whole diatribe about how EVElopedia had an item database, we don't, and how that lack of a database serves for good (we struggle enough trying to maintain things) and bad (Lack of exact stats in many places unless you go to EVE Ref). I appreciate the spirit of adding a Gecko page and in the effort provided. But we don't have the infrastructure in templates to properly support it just yet. That doesn't mean we shouldn't have the page, just that we should get that infrastructure so that pages like this one can have an appropriate layout. | |||
He also did some maintenance edits to [[Capital Ship Modules]], a page I had created. So he gets some brownie points from me for that. | |||
Edit summaries aren't really present in many cases. The edits are granular, perhaps too granular IMO, and often limited to a subsection, which does provide some information. Vult is not linked up with Uni services from what I can tell. | |||
}} | }} | ||
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%| | ||
| Line 3,563: | Line 3,498: | ||
good job | good job | ||
}} | }} | ||
|} | |} | ||
==Judges' comment analysis== | |||
Wiki Manager reviewed freeform comments submitted by Judges and how they thought each editor [[UniWiki:Wiki_Curator_Program#Becoming_a_Wiki_Curator|demonstrated excellence]]. It was possible to demonstrate excellence in seven ways. If no Judge made a comment about a category of excellence, an editor would receive a Not Applicable (NA) grade for that category. Editors with fewer NA grades did better during the Event in the eyes of the Judges. | |||
Judges' favor notes if at least one Judge highly valued and praised an editor's contribution. It also notes if at least one Judge expressed the opposite sentiment. | |||
{| class="wikitable sortable" | |||
! Editor !! NA count !! Judges' favor | |||
|- | |||
| Boundbylife || 0 || Excellence prize | |||
|- | |||
| Mednik Breau || 0 || Excellence prize | |||
|- | |||
| Elan Vital || 1 || | |||
|- | |||
| Amfion Bravais || 2 || | |||
|- | |||
| Mrbah Chieve || 2 || | |||
|- | |||
| Pancake33 || 2 || | |||
|- | |||
| Clio Usoko || 3 || | |||
|- | |||
| Crayox13 || 3 || | |||
|- | |||
| Gabriel CHL || 3 || | |||
|- | |||
| Gilmin Wells || 3 || Excellence prize | |||
|- | |||
| Monsignor Shimaya || 3 || | |||
|- | |||
| Shaemus O'Conor || 3 || | |||
|- | |||
| Vatrin || 3 || | |||
|- | |||
| Vult Skerris || 3 || | |||
|- | |||
| Amoni Panala || 4 || | |||
|- | |||
| Dossoles Hunter || 4 || | |||
|- | |||
| Duke Shasta || 4 || | |||
|- | |||
| Khai Emmerald || 4 || | |||
|- | |||
| Sumfin 7-34 || 4 || | |||
|- | |||
| DannyBac0n || 5 || | |||
|- | |||
| Celtic Raven || 6 || | |||
|- | |||
| Extra-DIvine Masculine Man || 6 || | |||
|- | |||
| Principeborghese || 6 || No prize | |||
|- | |||
| Suvas Orti || 6 || | |||
|- | |||
| Gurna Smunkle || 7 || No prize | |||
|} | |||
==Excellence, Participation and Overflow prizes== | |||
The goal of the judging process was to determine who should receive each [https://forum.eveuniversity.org/viewtopic.php?p=961884#p961884 prize]: | |||
* Excellence prize, from 1st to 5th place | |||
* Participation raffle, PLEX tier and ISK tier, can only be received if an editor hasn't received an Excellence prize | |||
An additional Overflow raffle was created due to excess of funds and distributed randomly between all editors. | |||
{| class="wikitable sortable" | |||
! Editor !! Excellence rank !! Participation raffle<ref name="PLEX"></ref> !! Overflow raffle<ref name="Overflow"></ref> !! Total ISK | |||
|- | |||
| Mednik Breau || 1st || x || x || 941M | |||
|- | |||
| Boundbylife || 2nd || x || x || 775M | |||
|- | |||
| Gilmin Wells || 3rd || x || x || 608M | |||
|- | |||
| Elan Vital || 4th || x || x || 441M | |||
|- | |||
| Pancake33 || 5th || x || x || 275M | |||
|- | |||
| Amfion Bravais || x || PLEX tier || x || 154M | |||
|- | |||
| Mrbah Chieve || x || PLEX tier || Won || 254M | |||
|- | |||
| Clio Usoko || x || ISK tier || x || 100M | |||
|- | |||
| Crayox13 || x || ISK tier || Won || 200M | |||
|- | |||
| Gabriel CHL || x || ISK tier || Won || 200M | |||
|- | |||
| Monsignor Shimaya || x || PLEX tier || x || 154M | |||
|- | |||
| Shaemus O'Conor || x || PLEX tier || Won || 254M | |||
|- | |||
| Vatrin || x || ISK tier || Won || 200M | |||
|- | |||
| Vult Skerris || x || ISK tier || Won || 200M | |||
|- | |||
| Amoni Panala || x || ISK tier || x || 100M | |||
|- | |||
| Dossoles Hunter || x || ISK tier || Won || 200M | |||
|- | |||
| Duke Shasta || x || PLEX tier || x || 154M | |||
|- | |||
| Khai Emmerald || x || PLEX tier || x || 154M | |||
|- | |||
| Sumfin 7-34 || x || ISK tier || x || 100M | |||
|- | |||
| DannyBac0n || x || ISK tier || x || 100M | |||
|- | |||
| Celtic Raven || x || ISK tier || x || 100M | |||
|- | |||
| Extra-DIvine Masculine Man || x || ISK tier || x || 100M | |||
|- | |||
| Suvas Orti || x || PLEX tier || x || 154M | |||
|} | |||
<small><references><ref name="PLEX">PLEX converted to ISK at a rate of 5.4M ISK per PLEX, 100% Jita Sell, to ease prize administration and distribution.</ref> | |||
<ref name="Overflow">After drawing Participation raffle prizes, there were still 7 ISK tier prizes that weren't drawn.</ref></references></small> | |||
Toggle search
Toggle menu
4.5K
7.6K
15.6K
232.1K
EVE University Wiki