User:Arin Mara/Sandbox/Judging/Beautify the Wiki 20th EVE University Anniversary: Difference between revisions

← Older edit Newer edit →

VisualWikitext

@@ Line 13: / Line 13: @@
 ==Judging==
-The goal of the judging process is to determine who should receive each [https://forum.eveuniversity.org/viewtopic.php?p=961884#p961884 prize]. Only those editors that made a well intentioned concerted effort to improve the Wiki are eligible for prizes.
+The goal of the judging process is to determine who should receive each [https://forum.eveuniversity.org/viewtopic.php?p=961884#p961884 prize]:
+* Excellence prize, from 1st to 5th place
+* Participation raffle, PLEX tier and ISK tier, can only be recieved if an editor hasn't received an Excellence prize
-The [[User:Arin Mara|Wiki Manager]] will shoulder the burden of making final judgements, judging intentions, resolving ambiguity and awarding prizes.
+Only those editors that made a well intentioned concerted effort to improve the Wiki are eligible to recieve a prize.
-* Judging will take place on the Wiki itself so that New Eden can see how Judges think and what they value
+===Judges===
-* Judges are members of the [[Wiki Department]] or the [https://forum.eveuniversity.org/viewtopic.php?p=961885#p961885 Event's Patrons]
-* Judges will consider the totality of an editor's work during the Event
-* Judges make their judgment known by writing a comment in the "X's comments" green box
-* Judges' comments are freeform but should consider how an editor [[UniWiki:Wiki_Curator_Program#Becoming_a_Wiki_Curator|demonstrated excellence]]:
-** Completed a Wiki Project, a task from the [[UniWiki:To-Do List]] or [[UniWiki:Patch Notes]]?
-** Made use of [[UniWiki:Editing Guide#Drafts and User Pages|User Namespace]]?
-** Made or improved a [[:Category:Template|template]]?
-** Followed [[UniWiki:Manual of Style]] or [[UniWiki:Welcome#UniWiki ideals|UniWiki Ideals]]?
-** Shown confidence or deferred judgement?
-** Communicated and cooperated with others?
-** Wrote expressive edit summaries?
-* Judges are suggested to write their comments constructively, as Stars and Wishes. For example:
-** Wishes:
-*** "To get a Participation prize, I'd like to have see X."
-*** "I'd like these tables to look more like those on [[Epic arcs]]."
-** Stars:
-*** "I love how X helped other editors like Y."
-*** "X made great use of their User Namespace."
-===Restrictions===
+Judges are members of the [[Wiki Department]], the [https://forum.eveuniversity.org/viewtopic.php?p=961885#p961885 Event's Patrons] or reputable capsuleers invited by the [[User:Arin Mara|Wiki Manager]].
+* Wiki Manager - shoulders the burden of making final judgements, judging intentions, resolving ambiguity and awarding prizes - deliberates after other Judges
+** [[User:Arin Mara]]
+* Wiki Curator - makes recommendations and gives explanations why an editor should receive a prize
+** Evon
+** Salartarium
+** Drebin
+* Event's Patron - makes recommendations and gives explanations why an editor should receive a prize
+** ToDo Patron list
+* Reputable Capsuleers - makes recommendations and gives explanations why an editor should receive a prize
+** ToDo Reputable Capsuleer list
+===Judging process===
+Judges will consider the totality of an editor's work during the Event, not just edits, except work that's excluded.
+Judges make their judgment known by writing a comment in the green comment box. Judges' comments are freeform but must at a minimum provide answers to how an editor [[UniWiki:Wiki_Curator_Program#Becoming_a_Wiki_Curator|demonstrated excellence]]. Judges should answer these questions for each editor:
+* Completed a Wiki Project, a task from the [[UniWiki:To-Do List]] or [[UniWiki:Patch Notes]]?
+* Made use of [[UniWiki:Editing Guide#Drafts and User Pages|User Namespace]]?
+* Made or improved a [[:Category:Template|template]]?
+* Followed [[UniWiki:Manual of Style]] or [[UniWiki:Welcome#UniWiki ideals|UniWiki Ideals]]?
+* Shown confidence or deferred judgement?
+* Communicated and cooperated with others?
+* Wrote expressive edit summaries?
+===Restrictions and exclusions===
 * Wiki Curators, Wiki Officers, the Wiki Manager and the Event's Patrons are ineligible to receive prizes
-* Improvements to articles listed in the [[:Category:EVE University]] or its subcategories are excluded from being judged - if found, delete the row from the table
+* Work on articles listed in the [[:Category:EVE University]] or its subcategories are excluded from being judged - delete them from the edits table
 ==Communication channel use==