User:Arin Mara/Sandbox/Judging/Beautify the Wiki 20th EVE University Anniversary: Difference between revisions

← Older edit Newer edit →

VisualWikitext

@@ Line 1,938: / Line 1,938: @@
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-So, I will say that Gabriel did put out a very nice infographic of the WHC's bookmarking scheme. If that had been added to the Wiki during the contest period, I'd say that he would have ''easily'' have been an excellence candidate, in my mind.
+So, I will say that Gabriel did put out a very nice infographic of the WHC's bookmarking scheme on Discord. If that had been added to the Wiki during the contest period, I'd say that he would have ''easily'' have been an excellence candidate, in my mind.
-But it wasn't. So going off of what was added during the contest period, having the probe scanners is a very nice addition! A cool thing to see! Edit summary was concise. No wiki-related communication I could immediately find.
+But it wasn't. So going off of what was added during the contest period, having the probe window icons is a very nice addition! A cool thing to see! Edit summary was concise. No wiki-related communication I could immediately find.
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 2,107: / Line 2,107: @@
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+Some good edits here. The additional images in particular are much appreciated.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 2,159: / Line 2,158: @@
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+Nothing more to add.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 2,260: / Line 2,258: @@
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+Good maintenance edits.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 2,752: / Line 2,749: @@
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+Lot of good maintenance edits. The kind of attention to our wide breadth of pages that we could most certainly use.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 2,806: / Line 2,802: @@
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+I have nothing to add to what the other judges have already said.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 2,875: / Line 2,870: @@
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+Good maintenance edits.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 2,951: / Line 2,945: @@
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+Disclaimer: I know Panacke through Incursions, so I might be biased.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
+Pancake appears to have been working with the Uni's abyss study group in updating the known rat spawns. I can also say that he attended the Intro to Wiki Editing class during the teach-a-thon, so he is most definitely engaged. Edit summaries could use some work though.
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 3,001: / Line 2,996: @@
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Somewhat useful information. Has become a standard bit of info for these sites so the edit shows familiarity with the wiki. A great approach to adding info is looking at what others have done. | width= 100%|}}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+A small but important bit of information. Always good to see these one-off edits of people just making a change that they feel is worth doing. Content wise it's not big, obviously. But small things do add up! :)
-Thank you for being a judge :)
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 3,102: / Line 3,096: @@
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+Lot of edits, though as far as the main namespace goes it looks like the only changes were to the streaming guide, the Short Skill Plan, and the Flight Deck. Some good maintenance edits to all nevertheless.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 3,187: / Line 3,180: @@
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+Very good styling edits on a breadth of pages. From a cursory look, I couldn't find anything I strongly disagreed with. Edit summaries were succinct and accurate.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 3,240: / Line 3,232: @@
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Very creative writing style| width= 100%|}}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+Added descriptions to battlecruisers that didn't have them. I don't know about the RP-style writing of them, given that the other ships don't have summaries with that sort of angle. But greatly appreciate the spirit of it.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 3,299: / Line 3,290: @@
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Using the update template is a good way for new players to contribute. Flagging old content helps alert other editors and ensure readers don't rely on the wrong information. Creating a user page is important for participating in the wiki.| width= 100%|}}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+Tomlin was another person who attended the Intro to Wiki Editing event. One of the things I mentioned in that class was that even if you weren't sure how to fix something, just flagging it with an update template was good in order to flag whatever you think is an issue as an issue, and that someone else might be able to get to it. And going down these names in alphabetical order, I'm getting a story in reverse, how an update request from Vatrin got Monsignor to add that safety column. Very nice story, that.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
+Aside from the class, I'm not sure if Tomlin has done any other wiki-related communications offsite.
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|
@@ Line 3,555: / Line 3,547: @@
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%|
-This is the place for your comments
+In my last batch of comments, I had a whole diatribe about how EVElopedia had an item database, we don't, and how that lack of a database serves for good (we struggle enough trying to maintain things) and bad (Lack of exact stats in many places unless you go to EVE Ref). I appreciate the spirit of adding a Gecko page and in the effort provided. But we don't have the infrastructure in templates to properly support it just yet. That doesn't mean we shouldn't have the page, just that we should get that infrastructure so that pages like this one can have an appropriate layout.
-Thank you for being a judge :)
+He also did some maintenance edits to [[Capital Ship Modules]], a page I had created. So he gets some brownie points from me for that.
+Edit summaries aren't really present in many cases. The edits are granular, perhaps too granular IMO, and often limited to a subsection, which does provide some information. Vult is not linked up with Uni services from what I can tell.
 }}
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%|