Difference between revisions of "User:Arin Mara/Sandbox/Judging/Beautify the Wiki 20th EVE University Anniversary"

Revision as of 08:48, 24 May 2024

Judging

The goal of the judging process is to determine who should receive each prize:

Excellence prize, from 1st to 5th place
Participation raffle, PLEX tier and ISK tier, can only be recieved if an editor hasn't received an Excellence prize

Only those editors that made a well intentioned concerted effort to improve the Wiki are eligible to recieve a prize.

Judges

Judges are members of the Wiki Department, the Event's Patrons or reputable capsuleers invited by the Wiki Manager.

Wiki Manager - shoulders the burden of making final judgements, judging intentions, resolving ambiguity and awarding prizes - deliberates after other Judges
- User:Arin Mara
Wiki Curator - gives prize recommendations and evaluates an editor's excellence (see #Judging process)
Event's Patron - gives prize recommendations and evaluates an editor's excellence (see #Judging process)
Reputable Capsuleers - gives prize recommendations and evaluates an editor's excellence (see #Judging process)
- User:Nessie Black

Restrictions and exclusions

Wiki Curators, Wiki Officers, the Wiki Manager and the Event's Patrons are ineligible to receive prizes
Work on articles listed in the Category:EVE University or its subcategories are excluded from being judged - delete them from the edits table

Judging process

Judges will consider the totality of an editor's work during the Event, not just edits.

Judges make their judgment known by writing a comment in their named green comment box. For example, User:Salartarium will make comments in the green comment box called "Salartarium's comments".

Judges' comments are freeform but must at a minimum provide answers to how an editor demonstrated excellence. Judges should answer these questions for each editor:

Completed a Wiki Project, a task from the UniWiki:To-Do List or UniWiki:Patch Notes? - working on these shows an editor is willing to do what's important
Made use of User Namespace? - drafting changes in the User Namespace shows an editor is well organized
Made or improved a template? - templates are tools that can be leveraged by others
Followed UniWiki:Manual of Style or UniWiki Ideals? - style and ideals are what bind all UniWiki users
Shown confidence or deferred judgement? - being bold, ambitious, yet knowing your limits shows good judgement
Communicated and cooperated with others? - helping others reinforces the editor's own knoweldge
Wrote expressive edit summaries? - the bigger the change, the more expressive the summary should be

Communication channel use

UniWiki uses a variety of channels for discussion and communicating with UniWiki users. When judging, consider how the editor communicated, cooperated and helped others.

Talk Pages have been captured as edits in the table of contributions.
During the Event, no one used the UniWiki Forum.
If the editor used EVE University Mumble, Judges will note it in their comment.

Discord public #wiki channel use

discord_nickname	date	message_count
Amfion Bravais	2024-03-08	1
Amfion Bravais	2024-04-08	1
Boundbylife	2024-03-07	2
Boundbylife	2024-03-08	8
Boundbylife	2024-03-09	1
Boundbylife	2024-03-11	1
Boundbylife	2024-03-12	2
Boundbylife	2024-03-13	5
Boundbylife	2024-03-18	6
Boundbylife	2024-03-19	5
Boundbylife	2024-03-25	4
Boundbylife	2024-04-01	1
Boundbylife	2024-04-04	2
Boundbylife	2024-04-05	1
Boundbylife	2024-04-08	1
Clio Usoko	2024-04-05	1
Clio Usoko	2024-04-06	1
Clio Usoko	2024-04-07	1
Crayox13	2024-03-05	7
Dossoles Hunter	2024-03-19	8
Dossoles Hunter	2024-03-23	1
Dossoles Hunter	2024-03-25	2
Dossoles Hunter	2024-04-02	5
Dossoles Hunter	2024-04-03	2
Elan Vital	2024-03-06	1
Elan Vital	2024-03-07	1
Gilmin Wells	2024-03-08	6
Kamille Panala	2024-03-04	1
Kamille Panala	2024-04-02	1
Mednik Breau	2024-03-04	21
Mednik Breau	2024-03-23	5
Mednik Breau	2024-04-06	5
Mednik Breau	2024-04-07	3
mrbah Chieve	2024-03-08	1
mrbah Chieve	2024-03-09	9
Shaemus O'Conor	2024-03-25	1

Wiki Edits

Amfion Bravais

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
EVEMon	2024-04-08 17:23:06	Clean-up tag implemented: removed references to EVE Fitting Tool (replaced with PYFA) and API keys (replaced ESI access). Minor cleanup of grammar and wording as well.
User:Amfion Bravais	2024-04-08 14:29:50
User:Amfion Bravais	2024-04-08 14:08:52
User:Amfion Bravais	2024-04-08 14:00:47	/* Officer Roles */
UniWiki:Projects	2024-04-08 14:12:05	/* To Do */
UniWiki:Projects	2024-04-08 14:11:28	/* To Do */ - Amfion Bravais: Changes to Homefront Operations Guide section.
File:Fleet Up.png	2024-03-30 08:01:09
File:Fleet Up.png	2024-03-30 08:00:55
File:Fleet Up.png	2024-03-30 08:00:03

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - EVEmon page cleanup, good edit summaries, categorization.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, EVEmon page and project, Homefront project.
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Yes.
Confidence and deferment? - Yes.
Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with many.
Edit summaries? - Good.

Evon's comments
Reducing the amount of cleanup candidates by taking up the EVEmon article Asked for peer review on Discord Use of the edit summary

Salartarium's comments
Remembered to add a category for images. Started a UniWiki project which is ambitious and shows that they are considering the needs of the wiki. Added to own User page which shows spirit.

Drebin's comments

A nice cleanup of the EVEMon page, though IMO I think the change of the character setup page from a numbered list to just a paragraph is a bit of a regression.

Merging the Uni medals and ribbons pages was a big lift. Don't know I fully agree with it at first taste, but I must acknowledge the accurate edit summaries and that it was, again, a big lift. Later edits did have Discord correspondence from Amfion, with nice details.

Turlough Dominian's comments

The edit to the eve mon section specifically to the set up character would of been a good chance to put a numbered step by step for easy digestion, the page is improved but could do with a little more step by step hand holding as its helping to setup something. I downloaded eve mon and followed the guide took me 2 attempts to follow as i lost my place in the reading hence why i think numbered step by step might be better. still very good edits

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Updated EVEMon page based on an clean-up tag. Requested review and feedback of edit on discord. Very descriptive edit summary.

Amoni Panala

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Creating a Scanner Alt	2024-03-18 12:20:50	BEAUTIFY - updating heading
Creating a Scanner Alt	2024-03-18 11:22:56	BEAUTIFY - added example fits
User:Amoni Panala/WIP/3	2024-03-18 11:18:58	/* Exploration example fits */
User:Amoni Panala/WIP/3	2024-03-18 11:17:53	/* Exploration example fits */
User:Amoni Panala/WIP/3	2024-03-18 10:53:20	/* Exploration example fits */
User:Amoni Panala/WIP/3	2024-03-18 09:42:41	/* Exploration example fits */
User:Amoni Panala/WIP/3	2024-03-18 09:32:32	/* Exploration example fits */
User:Amoni Panala/WIP/3	2024-03-18 08:13:49
Archive:Null-Sec Campus	2024-03-14 07:22:49	BEAUTIFY - added a link to the current NSC page since many people refer to this unaware there is a current NSC page
User:Amoni Panala/WIP/1	2024-03-14 06:59:49
User:Amoni Panala/WIP/1	2024-03-14 06:57:00
User:Amoni Panala/WIP/1	2024-03-14 06:52:22

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Fits that can be imported.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA
User Namespace? - Used.
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Yes.
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive.

Evon's comments
Use of user space Use of edit summary

Salartarium's comments
Used sandbox to formulate a larger edit. Added a fitting in the new acceptable way.

Drebin's comments
A good maintenance edit of the old NSC page. Fittings I do have to agree with Turtle about the EFTs not being copypastable ingame (I went and fixed that).

Turlough Dominian's comments
The addition of some fits is a nice little touch to the scanning alt page, but 3 of the 4 fits dont import fully ingame , Rangefinding Array I for example is not able to be simulated for me. as i am unable to import 3 of the 4 fits fully i shall down vote this one

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Good use of user namespace but most edit summaries were non descriptive. Reorganised Null-Sec Campus page and added new example fits in scanner alts page.

Boundbylife

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-04-04 23:34:06	/* Rules & Limitations */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-04-04 23:30:37	/* Rules & Limitations */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-04-03 18:10:52
Talk:Buyback	2024-04-03 18:10:18	/* Templated Update */
Talk:Buyback	2024-04-03 18:10:09	Created page with "==Templated Update== I think this page could use a facelift. I've got a prototype update to the page here https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/User:Boundbylife/sandbox . The prototy..."
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-20 14:15:01
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-19 14:05:06
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-19 14:02:39
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-19 14:00:39
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-19 13:58:35
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-19 13:57:02
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-19 13:56:08
Retired third-party tools	2024-03-18 16:57:09
Retired third-party tools	2024-03-18 16:56:27	Added removal dates for Eve-PySpy
Retired third-party tools	2024-03-18 16:55:15	formatting
Retired third-party tools	2024-03-18 16:53:55	Added Eve-PySpy
Talk:Third-party tools	2024-03-18 13:27:16
Talk:Third-party tools	2024-03-18 13:26:45	/* Removed PySpy */ missed a word
Talk:Third-party tools	2024-03-18 13:26:11	/* Removed PySpy */ new section
Third-party tools	2024-03-18 13:24:37	/* Intel Tools */ Removed PySpy, as it is no longer functional.
Careers	2024-03-13 17:10:42	/* Ratting */ added link to Ratting article
Kiting in Sovereign Nullsec	2024-03-13 17:07:30	added link to ratting page
Carriers	2024-03-13 17:06:19	added link to 'ratting' page
Surviving Nullsec	2024-03-13 17:05:00	/* Ratting */ added link to ratting page
Repairing security status	2024-03-13 17:04:06	/* Kill NPCs */ added link to 'ratting' page
Ratting	2024-03-13 17:03:13	Adde link to 'repairing security status' in the belt ratting section.
Needlejack filaments	2024-03-13 17:01:12	redirect to corrected ratting page
NullSec Ratting	2024-03-13 17:00:11	Redirect to 'true' ratting page
Ratting	2024-03-13 15:58:25	Adding a link to the NSC-specific ratting page. Need to clean that page up next, now that this page does most of that work
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 15:32:15	Replaced content with "- this is scratch space."
Ratting	2024-03-13 14:20:21	added a category
Ratting	2024-03-13 13:56:10	Creating a true 'ratting' page.
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 13:39:06	/* Security Level */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 13:38:30	/* Bounties */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 13:35:58	/* Belt Ratting */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 13:35:17	/* Bounties */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 13:24:07
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 13:20:41
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 13:20:04
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 13:15:49
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 13:01:49	/* Belt Ratting */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:54:23	/* Rare Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:49:07	/* Hauler Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:47:44	/* Belt Ratting Strategies */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:40:31
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:39:10	/* Belt Ratting Strategies */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:38:49
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:32:23	/* Ratting in Combat Sites */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:26:21	/* Building for target NPCs */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:25:37	/* Ratting in Combat Sites */
NPC damage types	2024-03-13 12:28:26	Undo revision 213843 by Boundbylife (talk)
NPC damage types	2024-03-13 12:27:27	moved closing tag
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:20:54	/* Ratting in Combat Sites */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:15:31	/* Ratting in Combat Sites */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 12:01:43	/* Ratting in Comsmic Anomalies */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:59:49	/* Mining Fleet */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:59:32	/* Capital Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:49:07	/* Capital Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:43:55	/* Capital Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:38:22	/* Hauler Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:36:02	/* Mining Fleet */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:28:05	/* Commander Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:27:55	/* Commander Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:26:33	/* Commander Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:26:24	/* Commander Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:25:50	/* Commander Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:24:29	/* Commander Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:17:25	/* Commander Spawns */
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-13 11:17:11
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 16:31:55
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 16:26:44
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 16:24:11
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 16:10:34
NPC damage types	2024-03-12 16:10:02	adding onlinclude tags for transclusion into a future Ratting page
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:55:04
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:54:32
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:54:23
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:53:46
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:52:09
NPC damage types	2024-03-12 12:53:30	changing subsection header name
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:51:33
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:44:10
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:43:58
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:39:55
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:36:31
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:36:14
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:36:03
NPC damage types	2024-03-12 12:38:40	Added a header to the initial section.
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:33:59
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:32:13
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:31:58
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:26:38
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:26:25
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:26:14
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:26:05
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:25:55
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 12:24:11
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 11:56:50
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 11:56:26
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 11:56:02
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 11:53:53
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 11:52:11
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 11:52:00
User:Boundbylife/sandbox	2024-03-12 11:45:42	Created page with "This is a scratch page. Nothing here should be taken for any real value."
Ship Replacement Program	2024-03-11 19:02:16	Added Service Status template
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 18:55:40
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 18:53:04
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 18:49:59
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 18:54:48
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 18:49:31
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 18:46:14
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 18:34:40
Flight Deck	2024-03-11 16:50:46
Fleet Support Program	2024-03-11 16:46:48	Added new Service Status template
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 16:37:30
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 16:34:36
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 16:31:48
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 16:30:56
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:32:50
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:32:35
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:32:06
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:24:03
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:23:27
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:22:24
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:22:04
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:19:10
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:17:24
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:16:42
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:16:01
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:14:02
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 16:21:04
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 16:14:43
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 16:12:25
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:10:26
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:06:23
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 16:04:46
Template:Infobox Service Status	2024-03-11 15:51:02	init commit
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 16:06:12
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 16:04:30
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 16:01:33
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 16:01:01
Template:Infobox Service Status/doc	2024-03-11 15:52:02	Created page with "; Description : This template is used to do something. ; Dependencies:
Template talk:EVE University	2024-03-11 12:56:14	/* Add new links */
Template talk:EVE University	2024-03-11 12:55:45	/* Add new links */
Template talk:EVE University	2024-03-11 12:54:54
File:Ping Channel Opt In Reaction.png	2024-03-11 12:31:28	Removing the Category tag for cleanliness
File:KB Post Mail.png	2024-03-11 12:30:06	As the article is deprecated, I am removing the category tag for cleanliness.
UniWiki talk:Announcements	2024-03-08 15:58:37
User:Chris Halsky/Buyback Proposal	2024-03-08 15:51:05	Removing scratch page from EVE Univsersity Services pagination, but leaving raw text if you were waiting to deploy it 'live'
UniWiki talk:Announcements	2024-03-08 15:34:46
UniWiki talk:Announcements	2024-03-08 15:34:16	Created page with "Did this ever happen? There are numerous {{ShipFitting}} templates around the wiki, enough that I know I've added some of my own, not realizing they were deprecated."
Flight Deck	2024-03-08 13:23:47	forgot to add bullet points.
Flight Deck	2024-03-08 13:21:28	init commit
File:Flight deck 2.png	2024-03-08 12:57:12
File:Flight deck 1.png	2024-03-08 12:56:22
Fleet Support Program	2024-03-08 12:48:30	init commit
EVE UNI Mapper	2024-03-08 12:18:56
EVE UNI Mapper	2024-03-08 12:16:46	Adding a new category to unify Uni services
User:Boundbylife	2024-03-08 12:17:23
User:Boundbylife	2024-03-08 12:08:40	Created page with "{{[[Template:#ask: Category:E-Uni Services\|#ask: Category:E-Uni Services]]}} Category:E-Uni Services"
Fitting missile launchers	2024-03-08 00:35:20	/* Battleship Class */ Migrated battleship fits to ShipFitting template.
Fitting missile launchers	2024-03-08 00:21:07	/* Battlecruiser Class */ Migrated battlecruiser entries to ShipFitting template.
Fitting missile launchers	2024-03-08 00:01:10	/* Cruiser Class */ No shield boosters? NOT AN ACTIVE TANK!
Fitting missile launchers	2024-03-07 23:57:13	/* Cruiser Class */ made cruiser available in TOC
Fitting missile launchers	2024-03-07 23:56:16	/* Cruiser Class */ Migrated Cruiser fit to ShipFitting Template
Fitting missile launchers	2024-03-07 23:41:00	/* Destroyer Class */ Missed some cleanup for Cruiser section.
Fitting missile launchers	2024-03-07 23:32:14	/* Destroyer Class */ Migrate Talwar build to ShipFitting template
Fitting missile launchers	2024-03-07 21:48:32	/* Frigate Class */ missed a bit of cleanup for Breacher migration
Perfect Refine List	2024-03-07 23:39:14	/* "Perfect" refiner list */
Perfect Refine List	2024-03-07 23:37:49	/* "Perfect" refiner list */
File:Kaeldahar.jpg	2024-03-07 23:37:13
Fitting missile launchers	2024-03-07 21:46:51	/* Frigate Class */ Migrated Mimnitar Breacher fit to ShipFitting template
Fitting missile launchers	2024-03-07 21:32:57	/* Frigate Class */ Migrated Kestrel fit to ShipFitting template.

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Many excellent edits.
Judges in favor of the editor recieving an Excellence prize.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Yes.
User Namespace? - Used.
Template? - Created.
Style and ideals? - Yes.
Confidence and deferment? - Yes.
Communication and cooperation? - Yes.
Edit summaries? - Excellent.

Evon's comments

Moved “hidden” fits from table to the ShipFitting template
Created and implemented “Infobox Service Status” template
Created “Ratting” article and implemented links to it on multiple pages, including redirects.
Created multiple services articles
Participation on #wiki and use of talk pages.

Maybe some more use of the “Show preview” option.

Excellence candidate

Salartarium's comments
Excellence Made a lot of edits. Wrote good summaries. Updated templates, and used talk pages and user space effectively.

Drebin's comments

Concur with other judges. Going to cop Evon's summary and label this my Excellence candidate as well.

The services template that Boundbylife created is quite simple. But it fills a need that was not being addressed by anything else before. And with a push now to put all services on the wiki instead of a hodgepodge of wiki, forum, and "trust me bro, this program exists". It's been fanned out to a variety of services already, which speaks to the need being there for this template. For that alone I'm willing to give that my recommendation.

Transclusion though I'm a bit iffy on. Those tend to not survive well if the transcluded page later gets restructured. Didn't happen during the contest period though, so no worries!

Turlough Dominian's comments
its alot to digest but if the information in the buyback sandbox example is acurate id say very good job and is of benifit, that took awhile to do for sure way to many edits for any sane person to go over fully but the random ones i did look at seemed ok and imrpoved the apearance along the way some miner edits also

Celtic Raven

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Dragoon	2024-04-06 16:11:53	BEAUTIFY

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Added a fresh perspective to a page.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - NA
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive.

Evon's comments

Nothing remarkable

Should make use of the “Edit summary”

Salartarium's comments
Page is now well polished. A good first edit that puts down what is common knowledge for veteran players, but might be surprising for new players.

Drebin's comments

I heard a take that the real value in a ship encylopedia, as it were, is not the raw stats of things (you can get that in-game, of course), but in those somewhat subjective yet collectively agreeable takes on what skills and tactics are good for a given ship. Given that the UniWiki lacks that for many ships, an edit that adds on to that is generally a good thing, so I appreciate the edit.

Using the utility highs of a Dragoon to salvage while ratting is something worth noting, as most other ships in its class would have to sacrifice something in order to do the same. Would want to see the comparison to the Algos though, as it has the same amount of high slots and could fit itself the same way as the hypothetical Dragoon fit (despite having five turret hardpoints).

Turlough Dominian's comments
minor edit of dragoon page

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Minor edit highlighting the salvaging capability of Dragoon in PVE, however non descriptive edit summary.

Clio Usoko

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
File:Contact Management Window Add Contact.png	2024-04-05 02:31:12	Clio Usoko uploaded a new version of File:Contact Management Window Add Contact.png
Contacts	2024-04-05 02:27:17	BEAUTIFY I have update the images in the top part of the section, to reflect the current contacts tool look and features. I have also update the text in the first section to be a bit more clear and detailed and a bit more formal. I have also removed reference in the first section to features that are not part of the current contacts windwow. I plan to update the rest of the page later to match the current game state.
File:Contact Management Window Add Contact.png	2024-04-05 02:23:47	Snapshot of Contact Management window with Add Contact button.
File:Contact Management Window.png	2024-04-05 02:12:19	Snapshot of Contact Management window.
File:Contacts Add Contact.png	2024-04-05 01:52:10	Snapshot of right-click and add contact menu after searching for contact in Search tab in Contacts window.
File:Contacts Contacts Tab.png	2024-04-05 01:31:48	Clio Usoko uploaded a new version of File:Contacts Contacts Tab.png
File:Contacts Contacts Tab.png	2024-04-05 01:02:05	Snapshot of the contacts tab in Contacts.

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Good edit summaries, updated contract page.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, updated contract page.
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - NA
Confidence and deferment? - Yes, contacted Drebin.
Communication and cooperation? - Yes.
Edit summaries? - Good.

Evon's comments

Of to a good start of updating/overhauling the Contracts article
Extensive Edit summary (Maybe even to extensive, but that might be a matter of taste)

Waiting for the promised update of the rest of the article.

Salartarium's comments
Significantly updated an old article that was increasingly becoming useless.

Drebin's comments

Full disclosure: I did help Clio out with some image version removals.

From that experience though, I can say that they demonstrated excellence in bouncing off of other wiki editors and contacting staff for help when needed. The content that was edited was small compared to some others who took part, but the Discord communication combined with the edit summaries does make me want to lean that way. If judging on the amount of work done, others would probably be more qualified for obvious reasons.

Turlough Dominian's comments
Contacts page - while updateing images to reflect what is current is an improvment visually the page is worse in my opinion, if the images where of similar size and location to the originals id award top marks but for moment i think it went backwords visually sorry

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Informative edit including 3 image file updates. Overly descriptive edit summary. Asked help on discord about file deletion process on wiki.

Crayox13

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Standard Sleeper Cache	2024-03-07 20:32:10	/* Quick Guide */
Standard Sleeper Cache	2024-03-07 20:31:38	BEAUTIFY step 7 an alternate method
Standard Sleeper Cache	2024-03-07 20:27:35
Standard Sleeper Cache	2024-03-06 14:06:42	Edited steps 3, 8, 9 and 10 from the quick guide
User:Crayox13/draft	2024-03-05 16:03:58
User:Crayox13/draft	2024-03-05 15:53:19	Created page with "{{main\|<Sleeper Cache>}} The Standard Sleeper Cache is a Cosmic Signature is a higher end and more complicated site which bears some resemblance to the basic Limite..."
Talk:Standard Sleeper Cache	2024-03-05 08:12:49	Created page with "I'd like to suggest an edit to the wiki page. It doesn't say to hack the nearby cans first after the drop in - that should be after step 3. It should also say to leave the far..."

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Communication, updated a guide.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Yes, updated a guide.
User Namespace? - Used.
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - NA
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with many.
Edit summaries? - Good.

Evon's comments

Communicated about the edit on #wiki
Used Userspace to test the edits

Looks like the “Show preview” button could be used more.

Salartarium's comments
Used draft and talk pages. Hard to tell if correct without doing the content. Lots of this stuff changes minutely without warning and updating small details like this helps keep track of everything.

Drebin's comments
I'm not an explo guy, so I can't judge the veracity of the Sleeper Cache page changes. I can say, though, that they did chat on the wiki channel in the E-UNI Discord extensively while making these edits, as Chanstaner said.

Turlough Dominian's comments

Immediately activate the afterburner and make haste towards was changed to Immediately active the afterburner and make haste towards , the wording feels wrong to me activate was fine as is , other than that the minor edits looked ok i have no experiance with sleeper cache so don't know if accurate or not.

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Small informative update, which was extensively discussed on forum and discord. Use of user namespace, with mix of descriptive and non descriptive edit summaries.

DannyBac0n

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Mission ships	2024-03-22 09:36:57	Added a ton of hyphens and correct a few spelling mistakes. Also removed unnecessary words. ( : BEAUTIFY

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Proofreading.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - NA
Confidence and deferment? - Yes, extensive edit.
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Good.

Evon's comments

Proofreading
use of edit summary

Note: Part of the spelling mistakes are not. Those are the difference between American and British spelling. The MoS doesn’t care as long as a single version is used throughout the article. As CCP is using the American version the wiki has a slight preference for that.

Salartarium's comments
Conciseness is important for long wiki articles and upholds the MoS on Words to Watch. Britain shall become Airstrip One

Drebin's comments

Yeah, short of a couple of typos ("missiles" in RLML, "traveling") and a style change, I don't know if I agree with the others for the reasons Evon mentioned. It is good that people are willing to patrol these big pages that we have around and put fixes when they see something they don't think is right, so I appreciate the edit in its entirety regardless. Concur on descriptive and effective use of edit summary.

Turlough Dominian's comments
Lots of good little spelling and grammer fix's, but armor was changed a number of times to armour while both spellings are correct armor is the spelling used ingame and should be what we use as its more relevent to the game imo

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Spelling correction and proofreading of a long wiki page. Edit summary is informative.

Dossoles Hunter

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Attempt to Overcome abyssal guide	2024-04-03 09:37:47
Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-20 14:30:57	/* Loot */ Fixed and compacting the loot section. added details on loot. BEAUTIFY
Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-20 14:28:48	/* General notes */
Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-20 14:27:48	/* General notes */
Serpentis Corporation Hydroponics Site	2024-03-20 13:58:49	/* Loot */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 18:52:55	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 18:35:50	/* General notes */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 18:24:34	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 18:22:30	/* Tier 0 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 18:21:13	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 18:20:45	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 18:16:24	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 18:15:29	Undo revision 214138 by Dossoles Hunter (talk)
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:58:21	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:56:52	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:55:25	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:53:26	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:53:04	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:49:37	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:46:05	/* Loot */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:45:21	/* Loot */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:43:10	/* Tier 0 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:36:03	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:28:11	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:27:29	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:25:54	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:23:03	/* Tier 0 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:21:26	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 17:18:31	/* Tier 1 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 16:16:51	/* Tier 0 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 16:01:17	/* Loot */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 15:53:46	/* Tier 0 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 15:50:21	/* Tier 0 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 15:40:36	/* Tier 0 Abyssal Deadspace */
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-19 15:33:21	/* Tier 0 Abyssal Deadspace */

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Great cooperation, use of Draft Namespace,

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA
User Namespace? - Yes, Halsky's.
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Yes.
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with many.
Edit summaries? - NA

Evon's comments

Working (With Chris?) in Chris Halsky’ draft space
No big edits, but someone has to do the small stuff

Could make some more use of Edit summary

Salartarium's comments
Great use of user space. Abyssals is content that benefits from having extensive written documentation. Unfortunately, some of these edits show the problems the wiki faces with having fittings and loot values.

Drebin's comments

Disclosure: I did poke Dossoles to remind him to put "BEAUTIFY" in one of his edits during the contest period.

Lot of good edits into a userspace page repository on Abyssals. Dossoles is very active on Discord and discussed the things he edited here, but there wasn't much in terms of edit summaries. Also, imaginary points do probably have to be reserved because most of the edits did not take place or manifest into the main namespace.

Turlough Dominian's comments
Lots of little additions nothing jumped out at me negativly , overall not bad and i do like reading a wiki page where the layout doesn't magically change for no reason so good imo

Chris Halsky's comments
Just to clarify - initial edits to "Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace" were done in my User space, as we didn't want to break the main page while we sorted out Tabs and stuff. It was later copied as a whole to proper space - without Dossoles' work we would not be able to.

Duke Shasta

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Alligator	2024-03-17 22:29:49	Added a missing linebreak and deleted an extraneous space.
Alligator	2024-03-17 19:22:15	Added a line on how to obtain Alligator BPCs
Cybele	2024-03-17 19:38:49	Minor spelling edits.
Mamba	2024-03-17 19:22:56	Added a line on how to obtain Mamba BPCs
Mekubal	2024-03-17 19:21:04	Added a summary.
Khizriel	2024-03-17 19:19:45	Added a summary
Azariel	2024-03-17 19:18:38	Added a brief summary about the Azariel.
Corruption and Suppression	2024-03-15 21:34:15	[Beautify] Added information about how corruption/suppression affects insurgency victory.
Faction warfare	2024-03-15 21:39:21

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Mix of edits, excellent edit summaries.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, typos.
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Yes.
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Excellent.

Evon's comments
Writing some “new” stuff. Fixing some typos and grammar Use of Edit summary

Salartarium's comments
I like the mix of edits for this user. Combination of basic typo and formatting fixes along with sprinkling in game knowledge. Shows that new editors can quickly start contributing good work to the wiki, especially in areas longstanding editors are unfamiliar with. Followed MoS and I hope they continue to contribute after this event.

Drebin's comments
Good maintenance work on the new ship pages to make sure that they are formatted properly and are a little less barebones. Edit summaries are concise and to the point.

Turlough Dominian's comments
Liked the addition of where to find blue prints for a number of the ships but i liked the Corruption and Suppression additional info the most for these edits

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Small informational edits about suppression mechanics in FW and summaries for Guristas Pirates ships. Brief but descriptive edit summaries.

Elan Vital

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
File:Add contact example.jpg	2024-04-03 21:09:47
File:Contacts window.jpg	2024-04-03 21:07:14
Fight Club	2024-03-07 06:37:03	Changed order to match image
Fight Club	2024-03-07 06:35:07	simple graphic of an arena
Fight Club	2024-03-07 06:06:20	Made a note generic so as to not ping people who no longer have a role
Fight Club	2024-03-07 01:33:29	added note about combat comms
Fight Club	2024-03-07 01:30:40
Fight Club	2024-03-07 01:28:33	minor clarification
File:Fight-club-arena.jpg	2024-03-07 06:32:17
Fight Club	2024-03-07 01:26:55	minor addition for clarification
Fight Club	2024-03-07 01:24:22	minor tweaks
Fight Club	2024-03-07 01:04:37
Fight Club	2024-03-07 01:02:12	Added sample host opening speech, sample MOTD, Discord Ping
Fight Club	2024-03-06 23:49:30	eliminated extraneous phrase
Fight Club	2024-03-06 21:04:54	removed word "members"
Fight Club	2024-03-06 20:59:19	readabilty edit
Fight Club	2024-03-06 20:52:57	Minor edit - copy and paste issue
Fight Club	2024-03-06 20:49:05	copy and paste error cleanup
Fight Club	2024-03-06 20:34:13	Beautify. Apparently, one has to paste their changes in for them to take effect. Reworking of Uni Fight Club event page.
User:Elan Vital	2024-03-06 20:45:54	/* Wiki Contributions */
User:Elan Vital	2024-03-06 20:42:24	/* Service */
User:Elan Vital	2024-03-06 20:41:39	/* Interests */
User:Elan Vital	2024-03-06 20:37:47
User:Elan Vital/Fight Club	2024-03-06 20:32:16	Edits before publishiing

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Fewer granular edits, use of Draft Namespace, documented events, good edit summaries.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, events.
User Namespace? - Used.
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Yes.
Confidence and deferment? - Yes, events.
Communication and cooperation? - Yes.
Edit summaries? - Good.

Evon's comments

Use of user space draft. But still quit a number of “small edits” in the Main name space

Find a use for the uploaded but not used images

Salartarium's comments
This will be a huge benefit for the reactivated Events Department. Documenting events bis a great way to preserve institutional knowledge for future generations.

Drebin's comments

A very nice expansion of the Uni Fight Club page. Given the attention that the Uni gives this longstanding event, a better page for it is much appreciated.

I agree with Chanstaner's points on the edit quantity relative to the changes. No Discord or talk page activity to note (Elan maintained the page near single-handedly for a couple of years, so it makes sense).

Turlough Dominian's comments
I think ping <proper Uni role for refreshing UFC contracts> is too generic of a change from what it was cause it does not give any clue who to actually contact even role wise. but other than who to ping for more contracts the page is really good the recent improvements are indeed majestic, also im totally biosed cause i love events and i used to host this in the past also long live fight club

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Comprehensive rework of the Fight Club page with a lot of new information, which may be useful to new hosts and participants. Too many minor edits for updating few words, but with descriptive edit summaries.

Extra-DIvine Masculine Man

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Arithmos Tyrannos	2024-03-10 16:43:15	/* Behavior */ BEAUTIFY and spelling correction
Arithmos Tyrannos	2024-03-10 16:37:36	Created page

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Content that can be expanded in the future.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - NA
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Ok.

Evon's comments

Created an article

Feels unfinished, no outgoing or incoming links, no category

Salartarium's comments
New content. Lots of WH stuff is still undocumented or not on the wiki even if its old. I'm sure this will be further integrated and expanded upon by others in the future.

Drebin's comments

Ooh. Pages like the one added on the Arithmos Tyrannos makes me *wish* we had an EVElopedia or EVEMon-style data dump of all the items in this place. Which I guess begs the question "Why not just use EVERef"? And I guess my answer is that while that's just a data dump, a wiki offers the potential to have both a data dump and some contextual information to better massage that raw data in the context of the things surrounding it.

Like with someone adding a Gecko page, though, we already struggle just keeping what we currently have up to date, and don't have the templates currently to properly support things like drones or specific rats yet. Adding literally tens of thousands of items would be a disaster maintenance-wise given our current plight.

Oh, uh, anyways, the contest. Content was sturctured fine. Some icon pizzazz and integration with other pages could be added, but again, the Wiki currently operates with expectation that there isn't a data dump item ID repository available. So to have that integrated for some rats but not others would be odd. And here I go again about the greater Wiki...

Lacking a summary for a page creation is understandable. No out-of-wiki communications that I am aware of.

Turlough Dominian's comments
good contribution a new page about a shinie npc who needs to die and a very good start to the page indeed , would love to see a picture of it added to the page but layout of page looks pleasent

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Created new page with good information. Could be improved with some links and refrences.

Gabriel CHL

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
UniWiki:Icons	2024-03-16 22:58:36	/* Probe Scanner */ typo
UniWiki:Icons	2024-03-08 00:24:55	/* Probe Scanner */ fix table style
UniWiki:Icons	2024-03-08 00:23:19	add probe scanner icons (BEAUTIFY)
File:Wormhole-unscanned.png	2024-03-08 00:12:38	wormhole (unscanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Wormhole-scanned.png	2024-03-08 00:12:30	wormhole (scanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Relic-unscanned.png	2024-03-08 00:12:15	relic site (unscanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Relic-scanned.png	2024-03-08 00:12:07	relic site (scanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Ore-unscanned.png	2024-03-08 00:11:55	ore site (unscanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Ore-scanned.png	2024-03-08 00:11:47	ore site (scanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Gas-unscanned.png	2024-03-08 00:11:31	gas site (unscanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Gas-scanned.png	2024-03-08 00:11:22	gas site (scanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Data-unscanned.png	2024-03-08 00:11:12	data site (unscanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Data-scanned.png	2024-03-08 00:11:04	data site (scanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Combat-unscanned.png	2024-03-08 00:10:54	combat site (unscanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Combat-scanned.png	2024-03-08 00:10:36	combat site (scanned) icon as seen in the probe scanner window
File:Wiki3.png	2024-03-07 23:59:41	Gabriel CHL uploaded a new version of File:Wiki3.png
File:Wiki2.png	2024-03-07 23:59:32	Gabriel CHL uploaded a new version of File:Wiki2.png
File:Wiki1.png	2024-03-07 23:58:41	Gabriel CHL uploaded a new version of File:Wiki1.png
User:Gabriel CHL/Test	2024-03-07 23:51:19	making a wiki how to guide

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Images, good edit summaries, if only the WHC bookmarking graphic was added to the Wiki.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Yes, new images.
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Yes.
Confidence and deferment? - Yes, lots of icons.
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Good.

Evon's comments
Upload new versions of images Upload “new” scanning related icons Use of Edit/upload summary

Salartarium's comments
Used edit summaries and user page. These icons are important as they are a basic building block for the wiki.

Drebin's comments

So, I will say that Gabriel did put out a very nice infographic of the WHC's bookmarking scheme on Discord. If that had been added to the Wiki during the contest period, I'd say that he would have easily have been an excellence candidate, in my mind.

But it wasn't. So going off of what was added during the contest period, having the probe window icons is a very nice addition! A cool thing to see! Edit summary was concise. No wiki-related communication I could immediately find.

Turlough Dominian's comments
probe scanner icons at the bottom of page look nice and in a perdie box

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Useful addition of new icons for the Probe Scanner window. Edit summaries are informative.

Gilmin Wells

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Overview	2024-03-12 02:48:20	Restructured some sections and finalized changes for the page, removing WIP tag
Overview	2024-03-09 05:02:40
Overview	2024-03-09 04:45:53	Included a link to Overview Settings for other methods of accessing the window. It's better for first timer users setting up to do the process in space rather than docked, so the link is included for extra study purposes.
Overview	2024-03-09 04:07:30	Updated the Brackets section to include a visual and brief explanation of filters vs bracket filters
Overview	2024-03-09 03:34:08
Overview	2024-03-09 03:31:46	Updated some descriptors to match what is in-game and included an image illustration for Locked Overview
Overview	2024-03-09 03:04:58	Included image illustrations for the right-click and radial menus
File:Filters vs bracket filters.png	2024-03-09 04:02:18	Filters vs Bracket Filters in Overview Settings
File:Locked column.png	2024-03-09 03:28:39	An example of a locked column
File:Overview radial menu.png	2024-03-09 03:04:00	Example of the radial menu
File:Overview right click.png	2024-03-09 03:02:16	Example of the overview right click menu
User:Gilmin Wells	2024-03-08 08:33:51	Included short About Me
File:Gilmin wells.png	2024-03-08 08:20:44	Portrait of Gilmin Wells
User:Gilmin Wells	2024-03-08 08:16:17	Included current projects
Overview	2024-03-08 08:10:19	Fixed some line-breaks and updated some copy
Overview	2024-03-08 08:08:10	Updated Overview Settings image to fit the rest of the illustration consistency
Overview	2024-03-08 08:05:23	Added more detailed steps with illustrations for Setting Up Your Overview
File:How to get to overview settings.png	2024-03-08 08:07:13	Updated image to fit the rest of the UI consistency
File:Overview eve uni channel.png	2024-03-08 08:03:03	The Overview EVE Uni channel
File:Accessing eve uni overview.png	2024-03-08 07:59:44	Example of how to access Overview (EVE Uni)
File:Open channel window.png	2024-03-08 07:56:21	Example of how to Open Channel Window
File:Overview settings misc tab.png	2024-03-08 07:48:41	An example of the Overview settings misc tab
Overview	2024-03-08 07:46:14	Included a Setting up your Overview sub-section (BEAUTIFY)
Overview	2024-03-08 07:22:32	Included an Understanding Your Overview sub-section
Overview	2024-03-08 06:42:10	Updated the Overview thumbnail
File:Overview settings 2024 update.png	2024-03-08 07:31:27	Visual example of accessing the Overview Settings panel
File:Overview content.png	2024-03-08 07:18:35	An example of the overview content
File:Overview tabs.png	2024-03-08 06:53:10	Showcasing the overview tabs
File:Overview eve university travel tab.png	2024-03-08 06:27:58	Gilmin Wells uploaded a new version of File:Overview eve university travel tab.png

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - , images, more use of Draft Namespace.
Judges in favor of the editor recieving an Excellence prize.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, page overhaul.
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Yes.
Confidence and deferment? - Yes, overhaul.
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Good.

Evon's comments

Article overhaul
Update and new images
Use of Edit summary

Could have used User space draft

Salartarium's comments
Excellence' Completely overhauled the Overviews page which is essential reading for all players. Used edit summaries.

Drebin's comments
Some good edits here. The additional images in particular are much appreciated.

Turlough Dominian's comments
good improvements, added suitable sized images, restructred the layour like setup overview is now b4 things like shortcuts and there was a bunch of not needed text at the start thats been moved away , all in all good improvements

Gurna Smunkle

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
UniWiki:Wiki Curator Program	2024-03-08 08:07:39	BEAUTIFY: Removed two sentences repeating redundant information

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - More effort and results.
Judges objected to the editor recieving a prize.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - NA
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - NA

Evon's comments
Edit summary says it all

Salartarium's comments
Demonstrates good judgment.

Drebin's comments
Nothing more to add.

Turlough Dominian's comments
yeah the removel of two lines is probably fine, would say that i feel not enough to be considered for taking part in the wiki event.

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Minor cleanup edit with descriptive edit summary.

Khai Emmerald

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
File:Shortcuts tab.png	2024-03-12 10:41:28	Khai Emmerald uploaded a new version of File:Shortcuts tab.png
File:Shortcuts tab.png	2024-03-12 10:36:29	Khai Emmerald uploaded a new version of File:Shortcuts tab.png
Talk:Character Sheet	2024-03-07 09:26:06	Created page with "I tried to update the jumpclone tab image, is it updated ? Because although the file is updated, i still see the old one"
Character Sheet	2024-03-07 10:23:06	Removed the Skill paragraph because skills are no longer in the character sheet (that count's as BEAUTIFY)
Character Sheet	2024-03-07 09:50:17	/* Biography */ Added some utilities of the Bio (does it count to BEAUTIFY the wiki ?)
Skills and learning	2024-03-07 10:19:47	/* Training skills */ again BEAUTIFY with links
Skills and learning	2024-03-07 10:15:23	/* Training skills */ Added the skill section from the character sheet (it's BEAUTIFY spree now)
Skills and learning	2024-03-07 09:56:17	/* Overview */ Rewritting information from the character sheet page which should no longer have the skill information (yes it's BEAUTIFY time)
File:Findcharsheet.png	2024-03-07 09:43:46	Khai Emmerald uploaded a new version of File:Findcharsheet.png
File:Standings.png	2024-03-07 09:39:48	Khai Emmerald uploaded a new version of File:Standings.png
File:Jumpclonestab.png	2024-03-07 09:20:26	Khai Emmerald uploaded a new version of File:Jumpclonestab.png
Slash Commands	2024-03-07 09:00:11	To BEAUTIFY this section, removed the ==== Movement (character in station) ==== because no character in station is not in the game anymore, edited the layout of the drone section
Frigates	2024-03-07 08:50:51	/* External links */ adding the 2023 BEAUTIFY frigates yearbook

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Excellent summaries, previous implementation.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - To-Do, updated info.
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Yes.
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Excellent.

Evon's comments
Upload new versions of images Remove outdated information Use of Edit summary

Salartarium's comments
Extensive edit summaries, used talk pages and was not afraid to ask questions. Maining these larger articles is hard without reading them completely and checking quite a bit of info.

Drebin's comments
Good maintenance edits.

Turlough Dominian's comments

I think the removel of the skills section from the character sheet could be argued either way could argue it is better somewhere else could argue its fine where it was, while the skills page is not fully on the charcter sheet there is still a button on the character sheet to navigate to the skills page and the info that was removed was well presented in an easy to digest box , tldr i prefered it as it was sorry that said in adition to the removed skills section it does require new images and a little tlc if it was to be kept

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Various small edits for updating outdated information and images. Very descriptive edit summaries.

Mednik Breau

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Asteroids and ore	2024-04-08 14:04:05	/* Low security space */ Spodumain, Crokite and Dark Ochre seems to not exist but not absolutely sure yet
Asteroids and ore	2024-04-08 14:02:18	/* Cosmic anomalies */ added Crokite and Dark Ochre; added Hedbergite, Hemorphite and Jaspet -- those definitely exist, will add pages soon
Asteroids and ore	2024-04-08 12:55:38	/* High security space */ add red link
Asteroids and ore	2024-04-08 12:52:40	/* Cosmic anomalies */ My experience (just flied around the circle through lowsec) and https://sistersprobe.fandom.com/de/wiki/Ore_Sites indicate those sites do not exist
Ice harvesting	2024-04-08 12:16:13	/* Ice distribution */ red link is better than no link (and I plan to add some of those pages soon)
File:Medium Jaspet Deposit.jpg	2024-04-08 12:03:05	Ore contents of a Medium Jaspet Deposit. Category:Ore sites
File:Large Hedbergite, Hemorphite and Jaspet Deposit.jpg	2024-04-08 12:01:37	Ore contents of a Large Hedbergite, Hemorphite and Jaspet Deposit. Category:Ore sites
File:Large Crokite, Dark Ochre and Gneiss Deposit-2.jpg	2024-04-08 12:00:03	Ore contents of a Large Crokite, Dark Ochre and Gneiss Deposit. Part 2. Category:Ore sites
File:Large Crokite, Dark Ochre and Gneiss Deposit-1.jpg	2024-04-08 11:59:50	Ore contents of a Large Crokite, Dark Ochre and Gneiss Deposit. Part 1. Category:Ore sites
File:Average Gneiss Deposit.jpg	2024-04-08 11:59:02	Ore contents of an Average Gneiss Deposit. Category:Ore sites
File:Average Crokite and Dark Ochre Deposit.jpg	2024-04-08 11:58:39	Ore contents of an Average Crokite and Dark Ochre Deposit. Category:Ore sites
Asteroids and ore	2024-04-08 08:14:33	/* High security space */ More details with addition of the name of anomaly
Asteroids and ore	2024-04-07 18:36:11	/* Cosmic anomalies */ Added Medium; added medium jaspet and medium arkonor and bistit
Asteroids and ore	2024-04-07 18:32:29	/* Cosmic anomalies */ Fix: incorrect info about varieties of ore
Clear Icicle Belt	2024-04-07 18:14:35	fix
Clear Icicle Belt	2024-04-07 18:13:23	It seems that highsec and lowsec have different quantities
Clear Icicle Belt	2024-04-07 18:12:11	Updated image from very ancient screenshot to current belt contents.
File:Small Hedbergite, Hemorphite and Jaspet Deposit.jpg	2024-04-07 18:08:58	Ore contents of a Small Hedbergite, Hemorphite and Jaspet Deposit.
File:Small Gneiss Deposit.jpg	2024-04-07 18:08:13	Ore contents of a Small Gneiss Deposit.
File:Small Crokite and Dark Ochre Deposit.jpg	2024-04-07 18:07:32	Ore contents of a Small Crokite and Dark Ochre Deposit.
Small Arkonor and Bistot Deposit	2024-04-07 18:07:05	better version of picture
File:Small Arkonor and Bistot Deposit.jpg	2024-04-07 18:06:30	Ore contents of a Small Arkonor and Bistot Deposit.
File:Large Crokite, Dark Ochre and Gneiss Deposit.jpg	2024-04-07 18:04:47
File:Large Crokite, Dark Ochre and Gneiss Deposit.jpg	2024-04-07 18:01:51	Ore contents of a Large Crokite, Dark Ochre and Gneiss Deposit.
File:Large Arkonor and Bistot Deposit-3.jpg	2024-04-07 18:01:25	Ore contents of a Large Arkonor and Bistot Deposit. Part 3.
File:Large Arkonor and Bistot Deposit-2.jpg	2024-04-07 18:01:12	Ore contents of a Large Arkonor and Bistot Deposit. Part 2.
File:Large Arkonor and Bistot Deposit-1.jpg	2024-04-07 18:00:51	Ore contents of a Large Arkonor and Bistot Deposit. Part 1.
File:Enriched Clear Icicle Belt.jpg	2024-04-07 17:59:40	Contents of an Enriched Clear Icicle Belt
File:Clear Icicle Belt.jpg	2024-04-07 17:59:19	Contents of a Clear Icicle Belt.
File:Average Hedbergite, Hemorphite and Jaspet Deposit.jpg	2024-04-07 17:57:25	Ore contents of an Average Hedbergite, Hemorphite and Jaspet Deposit.
File:Average Dark Ochre and Gneiss Deposit.jpg	2024-04-07 17:56:47	Ore contents of an Average Dark Ochre and Gneiss Deposit.
Medium Arkonor and Bistot Deposit	2024-04-07 14:50:04	Added scanner results
File:Medium Arkonor and Bistot Deposit.jpg	2024-04-07 14:49:04	Ore contents of a Medium Arkonor and Bistot Deposit.
File:Small Arkonor and Bistot deposit.png	2024-04-07 06:09:54	Ore contents of a Small Arkonor and Bistot Deposit.
Medium Arkonor and Bistot Deposit	2024-04-07 07:26:55	Created page with "{{NPCTableCSS}} {{main\|<Asteroids and ore>}} Medium Arkonor and Bistot Deposit are periodically spawned in nullsec systems. {\| class="wikitable" style="width: 440px;..."
Small Arkonor and Bistot Deposit	2024-04-07 06:49:29	cleanup template removed
Small Arkonor and Bistot Deposit	2024-04-07 06:48:22	Added scanner results; fixed thousands separator
User:Mednik Breau/Biomass farming	2024-04-07 05:52:42	/* Completing 750 CP milestone with several characters */ add link
User:Mednik Breau/Biomass farming	2024-04-07 05:45:42	/* Completing 750 CP milestone with several characters */ short retelling of pvp approach
Small Arkonor and Bistot Deposit	2024-04-07 05:01:31	updated rats
User:Mednik Breau/Biomass farming	2024-04-06 12:28:18	/* Known strategies */ changed time estimates for multibox method
User:Mednik Breau/Biomass farming	2024-04-06 12:14:31	/* Known strategies */ new subsections; added a bit of advice
User:Mednik Breau/Biomass farming	2024-04-06 09:55:37	/* Completing exploration */ Note: multiboxing
User:Mednik Breau/Biomass farming	2024-04-06 09:44:15	/* Known strategies */ exploration strategy added
User:Mednik Breau/Biomass farming	2024-04-06 07:34:32	/* Known strategies */ add
User:Mednik Breau/Biomass farming	2024-04-06 07:15:38	Create first version
Guide to AIR Career Programme	2024-04-06 07:27:34	/* Step 2 - Sisters of EVE Epic Arc: The Blood-Stained Stars - 51 missions to greatness */ fix
Expert Systems	2024-04-06 06:13:55	cleanup template removed: while the article is not excellent yet, it now contains relevant information.
Expert Systems	2024-04-06 06:12:45	/* New Eden Store Expert Systems */ added ship lists; did not fix missing icons -- better to provide icons than to hotfix
User:Mednik Breau	2024-03-31 14:24:07
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 19:53:42	Enforser operations: added skills from game; added commented out list of ships (needs prettification)
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 19:47:41	In the new descriptions the line sending to the old website was cut out.
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 19:34:48	/* New Eden Store Expert Systems */ Add icon
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 19:28:16	/* New Eden Store Expert Systems */ Import of new Expert Systems. Some fields left unfilled yet, work in progress.
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 19:02:08	Note that they are not tradeable; added a column with number of days for relevant systems.
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 18:45:44	Redistribute Mining section: 1 past event, 1 repeated event, 1 bought in NES. Renamed section "Empire Day" to "Seasonal events"
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 18:40:03	/* No longer available Expert Systems */ add sources
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 18:37:32	Isolated discontinued expert systems at the end of the article; moving sections around
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 18:30:42	Change to list structure to save vertical space
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 18:25:16	Preambule: elaborate on sources of Expert Systems.
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 18:06:03	Experiment: the longer lists of skills wrapped into {{SkillQueue}}
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 17:55:11	Added linebreaks in wikicode between cells in tables for better readability.
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 16:46:18	Double <br><br> in lists of ships -> single <br> for consistency and smaller tables.
Expert Systems	2024-03-24 15:45:45	/* External links */
Template:FactionWarfareNav/doc	2024-03-24 14:45:50	event links removed (main link stays for history, I think)
Shipcaster	2024-03-24 10:39:32	references as a section
Shipcaster	2024-03-24 10:23:25	Idea: add controversy to indicate they are more or less unused in reality
Interstellar Shipcaster	2024-03-24 10:38:34	Create redirect for search
Shipcaster Shadow War	2024-03-24 10:29:20	Added reference to shipcasters
Shipcaster	2024-03-24 10:04:56	beacons
Shipcaster	2024-03-23 22:23:12	/* Location */ locations from https://www.eveonline.com/news/view/introducing-the-interstellar-shipcaster
Shipcaster	2024-03-23 22:21:04	Stub with necessary future sections
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 21:56:24	Add {{FactionWarfareNav}} template; add Category: Faction Warfare
Ambition modifier	2024-03-23 21:55:00	Add {{FactionWarfareNav}} template
Corruption and Suppression	2024-03-23 21:54:27	/* References */ add {{FactionWarfareNav}} template
Template:FactionWarfareNav	2024-03-23 21:27:22	Add group for Pirate Faction enlistment. Preliminary population of this group.
Template:FactionWarfareNav	2024-03-23 21:21:47	Mark Shadow War as finished
Template:FactionWarfareNav	2024-03-23 21:20:45	Remove: additional details on an already outdated mechanic. They are still referenced in the main article.
Wormhole attributes	2024-03-23 20:46:43	/* Leading to wormhole space */ there exists another article; maybe they should be merged but let this at least have a link
Thera	2024-03-23 20:31:12	/* Stations */ Someone did the same list of services for each station in 2014 and it was not touched since. This makes no sense -- useless repetition.
Thera	2024-03-23 20:23:35	/* Stations */ deleted irrelevant information about Sisi testing IN 2014
Thera	2024-03-23 20:18:19	/* Helpful Tips for Visitors */ no longer relevant: Singularity is no more permanently available
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 20:08:49	/* Gates */ include map
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 20:03:29	/* Station */ incorporate superior version from https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/User:Devalt_Yotosala/Sandbox2
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 19:53:21	/* Station */ fix link
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 19:41:46	/* Restrictions */ partial revert: bubbles
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 19:37:10	/* Restrictions */ Import of better version from https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/User:Devalt_Yotosala/Sandbox2
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 18:59:51	/* Gate toll */ add: mass
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 18:32:39	/* Mechanics */ edit
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 18:26:12	/* Mechanics */ Fee exemption, dscan disabled
File:Zarzakh map.png	2024-03-23 20:07:10	The immediate connections from Zarzakh
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 18:19:56	/* Mechanics */ gate toll
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 17:37:00	etymology
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 16:47:06	/* Mechanics */ added
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 16:37:13	references as a section
Zarzakh	2024-03-23 16:35:38	Main info dump
Thera	2024-03-23 16:14:28	typographical enhancement: BEAUTIFY
User:Mednik Breau	2024-03-05 12:19:08	/* Abyssal diary */
User:Mednik Breau	2024-03-04 12:14:24
UniWiki:Projects	2024-03-04 11:37:07	/* To Do */ Border ores: current progress and remaining open questions
UniWiki:Projects	2024-03-04 09:25:22	Undo revision 213359 by Mednik Breau (talk)
UniWiki:Projects	2024-03-04 07:36:54	Want to take this one: ShipsMatrix. I had some ideas about it before and now that I see this one, they fit nicely together.
Mining	2024-03-04 11:28:56	/* Cosmic Anomalies */ name for A0
Mining	2024-03-04 11:23:03	/* Mission pockets */ rephrase
Mining	2024-03-04 11:21:45	/* Ore locations */ Split missions and anomalies. Provide details for anomalies.
Probe scanning	2024-03-04 11:11:13	/* Cosmic anomalies */ updated ore anomalies to "new" system
User:Mednik Breau	2024-03-04 09:20:30	/* Abyssal diary */
UniWiki:Projects	2024-03-04 07:35:25	There is some progress on border/A0

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Demonstrated excellence many times in multiple categories.
Judges in favor of the editor recieving an Excellence prize.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Took up a Project.
User Namespace? - Used.
Template? - Yes.
Style and ideals? - Yes.
Confidence and deferment? - Yes.
Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with many.
Edit summaries? - Excellent.

Evon's comments

Has taken on a project
Created article
Update article
Correct error
Rework redirect to article
update template
Create new images
Update Images
Use of Edit summary
Use of file upload comment

Excellence candidate

Salartarium's comments
Excellence Numerous quality edits on a wide variety of topics. used wiki best practices. Both reviewed and updated mining content which has been a longstanding ask, but greatly brought the wiki up to date with the latest expansion content.

Drebin's comments
Lot of good maintenance edits. The kind of attention to our wide breadth of pages that we could most certainly use.

Turlough Dominian's comments
Dang thats alot of edits, im not going threw all that can i just say good job and ty for all your edits :D

Monsignor Shimaya

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
List of data and relic sites	2024-04-06 22:41:59	To BEAUTIFY the page, I added columns and notes throughout the page to distinguish "safe and not safe" sites.

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Excellent style, a different implementation.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Excellent.
Confidence and deferment? - Yes.
Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with Vatrin.
Edit summaries? - Good.

Evon's comments

Added a column about site PvE safety to the tables. As the content of the cells is identical for all sites, regardless of security level I do not believe that this is the best solution for adding that information. Also the safety information is on the “Is this site "safe" to warp to?” of the Relic and data sites article creating multiple sources of the same information.
This edit seems to be triggered by the update banner added by Vatrin
use of Edit summary

Salartarium's comments
Extensive work for a first edit. Not a final solution to the page but will be built upon.

Drebin's comments
I have nothing to add to what the other judges have already said.

Turlough Dominian's comments
Looks good apearance wise, i lack data/relic knowledge to know if correct but it is a visually pleaseing imrovement

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Small but informative and beautiful edit. Edit and edit summary inspired by the update banner.

Mrbah Chieve

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Brassy Faced Bastard	2024-03-09 13:39:18
Brassy Faced Bastard	2024-03-08 22:22:28	completed the time bonus to be best of my knowledge
Brassy Faced Bastard	2024-03-08 22:06:01	changed the update tag.
Brassy Faced Bastard	2024-03-08 22:05:19	tried to beautify this page a little, added mission briefing. removed point and web from the Taibu State Suriage, as it seemed to not posess ewar, nor be an elite frigate. Added some info based on my assumptions with verify request.

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Used of templates, cooperated, great edit summaries,

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Update from To-Do list.
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - Used.
Style and ideals? - Followed.
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - Yes, async, using banner.
Edit summaries? - Great.

Evon's comments

Added content as ‘requested’ by the update banner
use of {{verify}} template for information the editor was not sure of.
Remove and re-add (with Verifiy tag) Suriage EWAR. Good solution for when in doubt.
Use of Edit summary

Note about edit summary 22:05: According to NPC naming conventions the Taibu prefix indicates Elite. Also the description on EVERef identifies it as elite frigate. EVE Ref also has a Warp Disruption Range for the Suriage

Salartarium's comments
Obviously looked at other pages and wiki documentation when making edits. Lots of this work will be a one time task and so this contribution will have a lasting impact.

Drebin's comments
Good maintenance edits.

Turlough Dominian's comments
indeed its improved i did like the addition of the misstion breif

Pancake33

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-20 09:00:28	Added necessary updates
Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-20 08:57:46
Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-20 08:56:07	BEAUTIFY
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-20 08:54:14
User:Chris Halsky/Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace	2024-03-20 08:49:35	Added tabs for tier 3-6
User:Pancake33	2024-03-17 01:31:16

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Attended Wiki class, excellent style.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Major knowledge addition.
User Namespace? - Used.
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Excellent.
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with Halsky.
Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive.

Evon's comments

Working (With Chris?) in Chris Halsky’ draft space
Published the work to the Main namespace.

Would like to see a bit more consistent use of the Edit summary

Salartarium's comments
Used user spaces, added to major initiative

Drebin's comments

Disclaimer: I know Panacke through Incursions, so I might be biased.

Pancake appears to have been working with the Uni's abyss study group in updating the known rat spawns. I can also say that he attended the Intro to Wiki Editing class during the teach-a-thon, so he is most definitely engaged. Edit summaries could use some work though.

Turlough Dominian's comments
excellent formating this is my favourite so far

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Updated and beautified the page with tabs and add some new information. Brief and non descriptive edit summaries.

Principeborghese

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Peacock Nebula	2024-03-10 22:43:45	BEAUTIFY : Saying how far away the clouds are.

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Too minor, but in the spirit of the Wiki.
Judges objected to the editor recieving a prize.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - NA
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Used.

Evon's comments
Added information to existing article Use Edit summary

Salartarium's comments
Somewhat useful information. Has become a standard bit of info for these sites so the edit shows familiarity with the wiki. A great approach to adding info is looking at what others have done.

Drebin's comments
A small but important bit of information. Always good to see these one-off edits of people just making a change that they feel is worth doing. Content wise it's not big, obviously. But small things do add up! :)

Turlough Dominian's comments
Not enough to be considered for wiki event IMO

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Minor informative edit with descriptive edit summary.

Shaemus O'Conor

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
User:Shaemus O'Conor	2024-04-08 14:04:35	/* Awards: */
User:Shaemus O'Conor	2024-04-08 06:57:09	/* Awards: */ added awarded flavour
User:Shaemus O'Conor	2024-04-07 14:32:25	added new medals
User:Shaemus O'Conor	2024-03-25 07:11:50	changed Logistics Officer to the new name Quartermaster Officer
Twitch Streaming Guide	2024-03-21 11:51:14	/* Single Objects */ added OBS frame with ticker box and Uni logo GIF
File:OBS Frame Ticker Box.png	2024-03-21 11:48:31
File:OBS Frame Ticker Box.png	2024-03-21 11:48:14	OBS empty frame with space for avatar or logo plus ticker box at the bottom
Flight Deck	2024-03-14 10:09:44	/* Flight Deck locations */ repaired listing (table ate the first ship entry in each line), added missing Derptrons
Flight Deck	2024-03-14 09:57:27	/* Flight Deck locations */ removed Innuendo (not a valid destination currently), removed Abyssal Tristan (not offered currently)
Flight Deck	2024-03-14 09:55:39	restructured order, put specialized Evermark and UFC ships at the end, integrated UFC fits into main UFC bullet point
File:Uniwiki Pub Quiz.jpg	2024-03-09 15:32:50
File:Uniwiki Pub Quiz.jpg	2024-03-09 15:32:28	For Wiki Pub Quizzes
Short Skill Plan	2024-03-06 08:43:40	/* Frigates */ added Condor to fast tackle

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Excellent edit summaries, categorization.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Yes.
Confidence and deferment? - Yes.
Communication and cooperation? - Good.
Edit summaries? - Excellent.

Evon's comments

Added category to the editors file uploads.

Unfortunately Flight Deck and Twitch Streaming Guide are categorized as EVE University and are thus not eligible for the contest. I do think however that the twitch guide could be differently categorized as only part of the information is E-UNI specific.

Salartarium's comments
Used best practices.

Drebin's comments
Lot of edits, though as far as the main namespace goes it looks like the only changes were to the streaming guide, the Short Skill Plan, and the Flight Deck. Some good maintenance edits to all nevertheless.

Turlough Dominian's comments
nothing major nice little bits here and there

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Updated Uni flight deck location and ships. Very descriptive edit summaries.

Sumfin 7-34

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
SCC Secure Key Storage	2024-03-14 00:36:00
SCC Secure Key Storage	2024-03-14 00:35:29
Sansha's Command Relay Outpost	2024-03-09 18:26:36	/* Room 1 */
Sansha's Command Relay Outpost	2024-03-09 18:25:24	Edited spelling and grammar, and updated Room 2 DPS to March 2024. Entry into the BEAUTIFY contest.
Angel Repurposed Outpost	2024-03-09 18:18:26	Edited spelling and grammar, and BPC drops to March 2024. Entry into the BEAUTIFY contest.
Serpentis Narcotic Warehouses	2024-03-09 18:17:22	Edited spelling and grammar, and escalation data to March 2024. Entry into the BEAUTIFY contest.
Serpentis Narcotic Warehouses	2024-03-09 18:13:46	Edited spelling and grammar, and updated module strengths to March 2024. Entry into the BEAUTIFY contest.
Creating a portable EVE Client	2024-03-09 18:07:39	Updating guide for 3/9/24 and running EVE from portable USB 3.0 HDD. Also an entry into the BEAUTIFY contest
Creating a portable EVE Client	2024-03-09 17:55:59

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Good summaries.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Proofreading.
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - In the spirit.
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Good.

Evon's comments

Mostly proofreading, but that is important to.

Note about Angel Repurposed Outpost: Editor changed rare drop from Dramiel to Daredevil BPC, might it be that both have a chance of dropping?

Salartarium's comments
Used edit summaries. Both updated information and extensively reviewed old.

Drebin's comments
Very good styling edits on a breadth of pages. From a cursory look, I couldn't find anything I strongly disagreed with. Edit summaries were succinct and accurate.

Turlough Dominian's comments
nice little edits here and there

Suvas Orti

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Battlecruisers	2024-03-08 09:46:38	/* Combat Battlecruisers */ Beautify

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - In the spirit, less copy and pasting.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - NA
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - NA
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive.

Evon's comments

Expand short ship descriptions from single word place holder to paragraph

Could improve the use of Edit summary

Salartarium's comments
Very creative writing style

Drebin's comments
Added descriptions to battlecruisers that didn't have them. I don't know about the RP-style writing of them, given that the other ships don't have summaries with that sort of angle. But greatly appreciate the spirit of it.

Turlough Dominian's comments
Bulk of the addition to the page is just a copy paste from another page, still decent addition but just copy paste job

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Minor informative edit. Text was copied from other pages without change or paraphrasing to suite the topic. Edit summary could be more descriptive.

Vatrin

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
List of data and relic sites	2024-03-17 15:50:20	BEAUTIFY the Wiki Event
User:Vatrin	2024-03-17 01:35:48	The Bio of an EVE player

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Attended Wiki class, used Update Templated.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Tagged content that needs an update.
User Namespace? - Added personal page.
Template? - Used.
Style and ideals? - NA
Confidence and deferment? - NA
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive.

Evon's comments

Added {{Update}} template
Created user page

Not the best use of Edit summary. It should describe what (technically) is being done. The summary of the editors user page describes what it is. Possible “better” summaries could be:

User:Vatrin – Create user page
List of data and relic sites – Add {{Update}}

Salartarium's comments
Using the update template is a good way for new players to contribute. Flagging old content helps alert other editors and ensure readers don't rely on the wrong information. Creating a user page is important for participating in the wiki.

Drebin's comments

Tomlin was another person who attended the Intro to Wiki Editing event. One of the things I mentioned in that class was that even if you weren't sure how to fix something, just flagging it with an update template was good in order to flag whatever you think is an issue as an issue, and that someone else might be able to get to it. And going down these names in alphabetical order, I'm getting a story in reverse, how an update request from Vatrin got Monsignor to add that safety column. Very nice story, that.

Aside from the class, I'm not sure if Tomlin has done any other wiki-related communications offsite.

Turlough Dominian's comments
Nothing of value was added only a suggestion of what should be added, if the suggestion had of been implemented by the submistion id say very good addition sadly its lacking

Chanstaner vi Adraille's comments
Minor edit. Used update template with reason but non descriptive edit summary.

Vult Skerris

Edits
Link	Timestamp	Edit Summary
Barghest	2024-04-08 14:41:24	/* Tactics */
Boundless Creation	2024-04-04 16:20:05
Boundless Creation	2024-04-04 16:19:53
Boundless Creation	2024-04-04 16:17:45
Viziam	2024-04-04 16:13:15
Carthum Conglomerate	2024-04-04 16:12:23
Scams in EVE Online	2024-04-03 17:44:01	/* How it works */
Scams in EVE Online	2024-04-03 17:42:46
Scams in EVE Online	2024-04-03 17:41:28	/* Contract Scams */ Beautify the wiki
Phoenix	2024-04-02 16:41:53	/* Summary */
Moros	2024-04-02 16:38:36	/* Summary */
Revelation Navy Issue	2024-04-02 16:34:34	/* Tactics */
Revelation Navy Issue	2024-04-02 16:32:39	/* Skills */
Dagon	2024-04-02 16:29:56	/* Tactics */
Dagon	2024-04-02 16:25:16	/* Skills */
Dagon	2024-04-02 16:24:55	/* Skills */
Dagon	2024-04-02 16:24:22	/* Skills */
Loggerhead	2024-04-02 16:16:39	/* Tactics */
Loggerhead	2024-04-02 16:15:56	/* Tactics */
Loggerhead	2024-04-02 16:12:17	/* Skills */
Loggerhead	2024-04-02 16:05:42	/* Notes */
Zirnitra	2024-04-02 16:01:02	/* Skills */
Caiman	2024-04-02 15:57:09	/* Summary */
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:48:55
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:48:06
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:45:43	Beautify the wiki.
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:40:57	/* Skills */
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:39:23	/* Skills */
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:33:33
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:32:12
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:31:21
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:30:34
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:30:05
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:29:24	/* Summary */
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:28:42
Gecko	2024-03-28 20:15:56	{{[[Template:#if:{{[[Template:{mode\|{mode]]}}}\|#if:{{[[Template:{mode\|{mode]]}}}]]\|<{{[[Template:#switch:{{[[Template:{mode\|{mode]]}}}\|#switch:{{[[Template:{mode\|{mode]]}}}]]}}>\|<ShipArticle>}}
File:UploadFile.png	2024-03-28 20:23:33	Vult Skerris reverted File:UploadFile.png to an old version
File:UploadFile.png	2024-03-28 20:22:50	Vult Skerris uploaded a new version of File:UploadFile.png
Capital Ship Modules	2024-03-22 20:53:34	/* Gravitational Transportation Field Oscillator */
Capital Ship Modules	2024-03-22 19:57:37	/* Capital Industrial Core */
Capital Ship Modules	2024-03-22 19:52:28	/* Capital Industrial Core */
Capital Ship Modules	2024-03-22 19:43:57	/* General Modules */
Capital Ship Modules	2024-03-22 19:40:53	/* Dreadnoughts */
File:Disruptive Lance Icon.png	2024-03-22 19:42:00	Vult Skerris uploaded a new version of File:Disruptive Lance Icon.png
File:Disruptive Lance Icon.png	2024-03-22 19:40:01
Capital Ship Modules	2024-03-22 19:30:20	/* General Modules */
File:Jump Drive Economizer.png	2024-03-22 19:28:28
Capital Ship Modules	2024-03-12 16:36:31	/* Disruptive Lance */
Capital Ship Modules	2024-03-12 16:35:45	/* Disruptive Lance */
Capital Ship Modules	2024-03-12 16:30:48	/* Disruptive Lance */

Arin's comments

What did Judges' value? - Gecko, no need for template, improved pages, good spirit, fewer granular edits.

Project, To-Do and Patch notes? - Multiple To-Dos.
User Namespace? - NA
Template? - NA
Style and ideals? - Good path.
Confidence and deferment? - High.
Communication and cooperation? - NA
Edit summaries? - Could be more expressive.

Evon's comments

updated Capital Ship Modules
Created article about the Gecko. Whether the Gecko deserves its own article I don’t know but I do think that use of the {{ShipArticle}} template is not appropriate.
Added/expanded summary, tactics and skill sections on several ship articles
Added a “new” scam and did some proofreading on Scams in EVE Online

Could do with some more use of the “Show preview” option.
Should make use of the Edit summary

Despite no use of the Edit summary still Excellence candidate for me.

Salartarium's comments
Excellence' Lots of high-quality edits. Added extensive esoteric knowledge that would likely escape a player even if they played the game for decades. Was bold in adding page for the gecko.

Drebin's comments

In my last batch of comments, I had a whole diatribe about how EVElopedia had an item database, we don't, and how that lack of a database serves for good (we struggle enough trying to maintain things) and bad (Lack of exact stats in many places unless you go to EVE Ref). I appreciate the spirit of adding a Gecko page and in the effort provided. But we don't have the infrastructure in templates to properly support it just yet. That doesn't mean we shouldn't have the page, just that we should get that infrastructure so that pages like this one can have an appropriate layout.

He also did some maintenance edits to Capital Ship Modules, a page I had created. So he gets some brownie points from me for that.

Edit summaries aren't really present in many cases. The edits are granular, perhaps too granular IMO, and often limited to a subsection, which does provide some information. Vult is not linked up with Uni services from what I can tell.

Turlough Dominian's comments
Very good additions , i especially liked the ship/skin scam that was added also added the full pages for a gecko not just editing an exsisting page put up a new page and it looks tidy good job

@@ Line 1,513: / Line 1,513: @@
 | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Turlough Dominian's comments|width= 100%|
 Lots of little additions nothing jumped out at me negativly , overall not bad and i do like reading a wiki page where the layout doesn't magically change for no reason so good imo
+}}
+| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Chris Halsky's comments|width= 100%|
+Just to clarify - initial edits to "Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace" were done in my User space, as we didn't want to break the main page while we sorted out Tabs and stuff. It was later copied as a whole to proper space - without Dossoles' work we would not be able to.
 }}
 |}

Difference between revisions of "User:Arin Mara/Sandbox/Judging/Beautify the Wiki 20th EVE University Anniversary"

Revision as of 08:48, 24 May 2024

Judging

Judges

Restrictions and exclusions

Judging process

Communication channel use

Discord public #wiki channel use

Wiki Edits

Amfion Bravais

Amoni Panala

Boundbylife

Celtic Raven

Clio Usoko

Crayox13

DannyBac0n

Dossoles Hunter

Duke Shasta

Elan Vital

Extra-DIvine Masculine Man

Gabriel CHL

Gilmin Wells

Gurna Smunkle

Khai Emmerald

Mednik Breau

Monsignor Shimaya

Mrbah Chieve

Pancake33

Principeborghese

Shaemus O'Conor

Sumfin 7-34

Suvas Orti

Vatrin

Vult Skerris

Navigation menu

Search