User talk:Erwin Madelung

From EVE University Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Removal of SOCT and Triglavian Ships from Pirate Faction Ship Overview

A few weeks ago, you filed an edit to the Pirate Faction Ship Overview, which removed information on ships from the Society of Conscious Thought and the Triglavian Collective.

I believe the information on these ships should exist on this wiki, and so I ask you a question: If this information does not fit on the Pirate Faction Ship Overview page, where it was originally, Where should it go in stead? Because I partially agree with your "not considered pirate faction ships" reasoning, but I don't immediately see another (preferably commonly accessable) page where that information should go. Arexand Oskold (talk) 13:49, 23 November 2019 (UTC)

All the information are on Triglavian Collective and Society of Conscious Thought. I made sure that no information was lost. Most was redundant anyways. Be also aware that Pirate Faction Ship Overview is an overview. As such the section about those ships were much too detailed. The details should go on the corresponding pages. The SoE ships for example are too detailed on the overview page (112 words) while they could use some love on their factions page (129 words). In the end all those ships are very specialised though and the most care should be given to the spefic ship page. The amount of text for the astero seems good. The stratios and nestor are very short. (It's abviously not about the length in words but it's the easiest way to quickly demonstrate my point.) In general the nature of those three ships is very different although the very similar bonuses might suggest otherwise. The other pirate faction ships aren't that different. I only picked SoE as an example. cheers Erwin Madelung (talk) 14:12, 23 November 2019 (UTC)
Ooo yikes you're right, the main racial pages are a bit short... Well there's a few new directions to go in for my next week of editing. Arexand Oskold (talk) 14:57, 23 November 2019 (UTC)