Toggle menu
Toggle preferences menu
Toggle personal menu
Not logged in
Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits.

User talk:Devalt Yotosala/Sandbox1/Template:Infobox refiner: Difference between revisions

Discussion page of User:Devalt Yotosala/Sandbox1/Template:Infobox refiner
Arin Mara (talk | contribs)
Row granularity and machine readability
Arin Mara (talk | contribs)
m Conversation order
Line 100: Line 100:


: I'm concerned the table will have too much cognitive load for the end user. Instead of looking to see if a given refiner can match the needs of a user, the user must now keep track of the names in each category and cross reference those names against their needs to get a unified list of potential characters. --[[User:Devalt Yotosala|Devalt Yotosala]] ([[User talk:Devalt Yotosala|talk]]) 23:04, 29 July 2022 (UTC)
: I'm concerned the table will have too much cognitive load for the end user. Instead of looking to see if a given refiner can match the needs of a user, the user must now keep track of the names in each category and cross reference those names against their needs to get a unified list of potential characters. --[[User:Devalt Yotosala|Devalt Yotosala]] ([[User talk:Devalt Yotosala|talk]]) 23:04, 29 July 2022 (UTC)
: A filter drop down for Wiki tables currently does not exist. Perhaps there is an extension, but installing any extension involves calling in Bates to install it. [[User:Arin Mara|Arin Mara]] ([[User talk:Arin Mara|talk]]) 20:10, 30 July 2022 (UTC)


:: Is it possible to break the original template into multiple rows - "Asteroid Ores", "Moon Ores", "Other" - then just type freeform into those boxes, which are at level V?  There's only what, five types in any one category?  We could use just simple text and only the single descriptive word, rather than linking to the full skill name - e.g. fill out the "Moon Ore" section of the template with "Ubiquitous, Common, Uncommon, Rare, Exceptional".  And don't hide these three sections in an expand box, just leave them as text on the profile.   
:: Is it possible to break the original template into multiple rows - "Asteroid Ores", "Moon Ores", "Other" - then just type freeform into those boxes, which are at level V?  There's only what, five types in any one category?  We could use just simple text and only the single descriptive word, rather than linking to the full skill name - e.g. fill out the "Moon Ore" section of the template with "Ubiquitous, Common, Uncommon, Rare, Exceptional".  And don't hide these three sections in an expand box, just leave them as text on the profile.   
Line 109: Line 107:
::: Making skill rows more granular is an interesting solution. However, the Infobox would still be tall if the information isn't collapsed. I don't mind it.
::: Making skill rows more granular is an interesting solution. However, the Infobox would still be tall if the information isn't collapsed. I don't mind it.
::: Skill names should be checked, their formatting enforced and the order of skills consistent. Making information machine readable is a huge boon. [[User:Arin Mara|Arin Mara]] ([[User talk:Arin Mara|talk]]) 20:19, 30 July 2022 (UTC)
::: Skill names should be checked, their formatting enforced and the order of skills consistent. Making information machine readable is a huge boon. [[User:Arin Mara|Arin Mara]] ([[User talk:Arin Mara|talk]]) 20:19, 30 July 2022 (UTC)
: A filter drop down for Wiki tables currently does not exist. Perhaps there is an extension, but installing any extension involves calling in Bates to install it. [[User:Arin Mara|Arin Mara]] ([[User talk:Arin Mara|talk]]) 20:10, 30 July 2022 (UTC)


== Template Goals ==
== Template Goals ==