Toggle search
Toggle menu
4.5K
7.6K
15.6K
232K
EVE University Wiki
Toggle preferences menu
Toggle personal menu
Not logged in
Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits.

User:Arin Mara/Sandbox/Judging/Beautify the Wiki 20th EVE University Anniversary: Difference between revisions

From EVE University Wiki
More actions
← Older edit
VisualWikitext
Arin Mara (talk | contribs)
5,648 edits
Second order judge, me, did a first pass over edits and first order Judges' comments
m Add <nowiki> to block incorrect links.
 
(8 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 30: Line 30:
** [[User:Drebin 679]]
** [[User:Drebin 679]]
* Event's Patron - gives prize recommendations and evaluates an editor's excellence (see [[#Judging process]])
* Event's Patron - gives prize recommendations and evaluates an editor's excellence (see [[#Judging process]])
** [[User:Menelmir]]
** [[User:Turlough Dominian]]
** [[User:Turlough Dominian]]
** [[User:Chanstaner vi Adraille]]
** [[User:Chanstaner vi Adraille]]
* Reputable Capsuleers - gives prize recommendations and evaluates an editor's excellence (see [[#Judging process]])
** [[User:Nessie Black]]<!-- Define reputable -->


===Restrictions and exclusions===
===Restrictions and exclusions===
Line 977: Line 974:
| [https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/index.php?pageid=22778&diff=213534 User:Boundbylife]
| [https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/index.php?pageid=22778&diff=213534 User:Boundbylife]
| 2024-03-08 12:08:40
| 2024-03-08 12:08:40
| Created page with "{{t|#ask: [[:Category:E-Uni Services]]|format=flatlist|sep=&thinsp;*&thinsp;}} [[:Category:E-Uni Services]]"
| Created page with <nowiki>"{{t|#ask: [[:Category:E-Uni Services]]|format=flatlist|sep=&thinsp;*&thinsp;}} [[:Category:E-Uni Services]]"</nowiki>
|-
|-
| [https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/index.php?pageid=2644&diff=213507 Fitting missile launchers]
| [https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/index.php?pageid=2644&diff=213507 Fitting missile launchers]
Line 1,495: Line 1,492:
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with many.
* Communication and cooperation? - Yes, with many.
* Edit summaries? - NA
* Edit summaries? - NA
Chris Halsky's comments:
* Just to clarify - initial edits to "Possible rooms in Abyssal Deadspace" were done in my User space, as we didn't want to break the main page while we sorted out Tabs and stuff. It was later copied as a whole to proper space - without Dossoles' work we would not be able to.
}}
}}
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%|
| style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Evon's comments|width= 100%|
Line 3,499: Line 3,499:
}}
}}
|}
|}
==Judges' comment analysis==
Wiki Manager reviewed freeform comments submitted by Judges and how they thought each editor [[UniWiki:Wiki_Curator_Program#Becoming_a_Wiki_Curator|demonstrated excellence]]. It was possible to demonstrate excellence in seven ways. If no Judge made a comment about a category of excellence, an editor would receive a Not Applicable (NA) grade for that category. Editors with fewer NA grades did better during the Event in the eyes of the Judges.
Judges' favor notes if at least one Judge highly valued and praised an editor's contribution. It also notes if at least one Judge expressed the opposite sentiment.
{| class="wikitable sortable"
! Editor !! NA count !! Judges' favor
|-
| Boundbylife || 0 || Excellence prize
|-
| Mednik Breau || 0 || Excellence prize
|-
| Elan Vital || 1 ||
|-
| Amfion Bravais || 2 ||
|-
| Mrbah Chieve || 2 ||
|-
| Pancake33 || 2 ||
|-
| Clio Usoko || 3 ||
|-
| Crayox13 || 3 ||
|-
| Gabriel CHL || 3 ||
|-
| Gilmin Wells || 3 || Excellence prize
|-
| Monsignor Shimaya || 3 ||
|-
| Shaemus O'Conor || 3 ||
|-
| Vatrin || 3 ||
|-
| Vult Skerris || 3 ||
|-
| Amoni Panala || 4 ||
|-
| Dossoles Hunter || 4 ||
|-
| Duke Shasta || 4 ||
|-
| Khai Emmerald || 4 ||
|-
| Sumfin 7-34 || 4 ||
|-
| DannyBac0n || 5 ||
|-
| Celtic Raven || 6 ||
|-
| Extra-DIvine Masculine Man || 6 ||
|-
| Principeborghese || 6 || No prize
|-
| Suvas Orti || 6 ||
|-
| Gurna Smunkle || 7 || No prize
|}
==Excellence, Participation and Overflow prizes==
The goal of the judging process was to determine who should receive each [https://forum.eveuniversity.org/viewtopic.php?p=961884#p961884 prize]:
* Excellence prize, from 1st to 5th place
* Participation raffle, PLEX tier and ISK tier, can only be received if an editor hasn't received an Excellence prize
An additional Overflow raffle was created due to excess of funds and distributed randomly between all editors.
{| class="wikitable sortable"
! Editor !! Excellence rank !! Participation raffle<ref name="PLEX"></ref> !! Overflow raffle<ref name="Overflow"></ref> !! Total ISK
|-
| Mednik Breau || 1st || x || x || 941M
|-
| Boundbylife || 2nd || x || x || 775M
|-
| Gilmin Wells || 3rd || x || x || 608M
|-
| Elan Vital || 4th || x || x || 441M
|-
| Pancake33 || 5th || x || x || 275M
|-
| Amfion Bravais || x || PLEX tier || x || 154M
|-
| Mrbah Chieve || x || PLEX tier || Won || 254M
|-
| Clio Usoko || x || ISK tier || x || 100M
|-
| Crayox13 || x || ISK tier || Won || 200M
|-
| Gabriel CHL || x || ISK tier || Won || 200M
|-
| Monsignor Shimaya || x || PLEX tier || x || 154M
|-
| Shaemus O'Conor || x || PLEX tier || Won || 254M
|-
| Vatrin || x || ISK tier || Won || 200M
|-
| Vult Skerris || x || ISK tier || Won || 200M
|-
| Amoni Panala || x || ISK tier || x || 100M
|-
| Dossoles Hunter || x || ISK tier || Won || 200M
|-
| Duke Shasta || x || PLEX tier || x || 154M
|-
| Khai Emmerald || x || PLEX tier || x || 154M
|-
| Sumfin 7-34 || x || ISK tier || x || 100M
|-
| DannyBac0n || x || ISK tier || x || 100M
|-
| Celtic Raven || x || ISK tier || x || 100M
|-
| Extra-DIvine Masculine Man || x || ISK tier || x || 100M
|-
| Suvas Orti || x || PLEX tier || x || 154M
|}
<small><references><ref name="PLEX">PLEX converted to ISK at a rate of 5.4M ISK per PLEX, 100% Jita Sell, to ease prize administration and distribution.</ref>
<ref name="Overflow">After drawing Participation raffle prizes, there were still 7 ISK tier prizes that weren't drawn.</ref></references></small>
Retrieved from "https://wiki.eveuniversity.org/User:Arin_Mara/Sandbox/Judging/Beautify_the_Wiki_20th_EVE_University_Anniversary"