|
|
| Line 209: |
Line 209: |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | A nice cleanup of the EVEMon page, though IMO I think the change of the character setup page from a numbered list to just a paragraph is a bit of a regression. |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| + | |
| | + | Merging the Uni medals and ribbons pages was a big lift. Don't know I fully agree with it at first taste, but I must acknowledge the accurate edit summaries and that it was, again, a big lift. Later edits did have Discord correspondence from Amfion, with nice details. |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
| Line 307: |
Line 308: |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | A good maintenance edit of the old NSC page. Fittings I do have to agree with Turtle about the EFTs not being copypastable ingame (I went and fixed that). |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
| Line 1,057: |
Line 1,057: |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | Concur with other judges. Going to cop Evon's summary and label this my {{Co|yellow|Excellence candidate}} as well. |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| + | |
| | + | The services template that Boundbylife created is quite simple. But it fills a need that was not being addressed by anything else before. And with a push now to put all services on the wiki instead of a hodgepodge of wiki, forum, and "trust me bro, this program exists". It's been fanned out to a variety of services already, which speaks to the need being there for this template. For that alone I'm willing to give that my recommendation. |
| | + | |
| | + | Transclusion though I'm a bit iffy on. Those tend to not survive well if the transcluded page later gets restructured. Didn't happen during the contest period though, so no worries! |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
| Line 1,111: |
Line 1,114: |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Page is now well polished. A good first edit that puts down what is common knowledge for veteran players, but might be surprising for new players.| width= 100%|}} | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Page is now well polished. A good first edit that puts down what is common knowledge for veteran players, but might be surprising for new players.| width= 100%|}} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | I heard a take that the real value in a ship encylopedia, as it were, is not the raw stats of things (you can get that in-game, of course), but in those somewhat subjective yet collectively agreeable takes on what skills and tactics are good for a given ship. Given that the UniWiki lacks that for many ships, an edit that adds on to that is generally a good thing, so I appreciate the edit. |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| + | |
| | + | Using the utility highs of a Dragoon to salvage while ratting is something worth noting, as most other ships in its class would have to sacrifice something in order to do the same. Would want to see the comparison to the Algos though, as it has the same amount of high slots and could fit itself the same way as the hypothetical Dragoon fit (despite having five turret hardpoints). |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
| Line 1,190: |
Line 1,194: |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | Full disclosure: I did help Clio out with some image version removals. |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| + | |
| | + | From that experience though, I can say that they demonstrated excellence in bouncing off of other wiki editors and contacting staff for help when needed. The content that was edited was small compared to some others who took part, but the Discord communication combined with the edit summaries does make me want to lean that way. If judging on the amount of work done, others would probably be more qualified for obvious reasons. |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
| Line 1,269: |
Line 1,274: |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | I'm not an explo guy, so I can't judge the veracity of the Sleeper Cache page changes. I can say, though, that they did chat on the wiki channel in the E-UNI Discord extensively while making these edits, as Chanstaner said. |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
| Line 1,323: |
Line 1,327: |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Conciseness is important for long wiki articles and upholds the MoS on Words to Watch. Britain shall become Airstrip One| width= 100%|}} | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|Conciseness is important for long wiki articles and upholds the MoS on Words to Watch. Britain shall become Airstrip One| width= 100%|}} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | Yeah, short of a couple of typos ("missiles" in RLML, "traveling") and a style change, I don't know if I agree with the others for the reasons Evon mentioned. It is good that people are willing to patrol these big pages that we have around and put fixes when they see something they don't think is right, so I appreciate the edit in its entirety regardless. Concur on descriptive and effective use of edit summary. |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
| Line 1,514: |
Line 1,517: |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | Disclosure: I did poke Dossoles to remind him to put "BEAUTIFY" in one of his edits during the contest period. |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| + | |
| | + | Lot of good edits into a userspace page repository on Abyssals. Dossoles is very active on Discord and discussed the things he edited here, but there wasn't much in terms of edit summaries. Also, imaginary points do probably have to be reserved because most of the edits did not take place or manifest into the main namespace. |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
| Line 1,598: |
Line 1,602: |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|I like the mix of edits for this user. Combination of basic typo and formatting fixes along with sprinkling in game knowledge. Shows that new editors can quickly start contributing good work to the wiki, especially in areas longstanding editors are unfamiliar with. Followed MoS and I hope they continue to contribute after this event. |width= 100%|}} | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Salartarium's comments|I like the mix of edits for this user. Combination of basic typo and formatting fixes along with sprinkling in game knowledge. Shows that new editors can quickly start contributing good work to the wiki, especially in areas longstanding editors are unfamiliar with. Followed MoS and I hope they continue to contribute after this event. |width= 100%|}} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | Good maintenance work on the new ship pages to make sure that they are formatted properly and are a little less barebones. Edit summaries are concise and to the point. |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
| Line 1,744: |
Line 1,747: |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | A very nice expansion of the Uni Fight Club page. Given the attention that the Uni gives this longstanding event, a better page for it is much appreciated. |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| + | |
| | + | I agree with Chanstaner's points on the edit quantity relative to the changes. No Discord or talk page activity to note (Elan maintained the page near single-handedly for a couple of years, so it makes sense). |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
| Line 1,804: |
Line 1,808: |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | Ooh. Pages like the one added on the [[Arithmos Tyrannos]] makes me *wish* we had an EVElopedia or EVEMon-style data dump of all the items in this place. Which I guess begs the question "Why not just use EVERef"? And I guess my answer is that while that's just a data dump, a wiki offers the potential to have both a data dump and some contextual information to better massage that raw data in the context of the things surrounding it. |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| + | |
| | + | Like with someone adding a [[Gecko]] page, though, we already struggle just keeping what we currently have up to date, and don't have the templates currently to properly support things like drones or specific rats yet. Adding literally tens of thousands of items would be a disaster maintenance-wise given our current plight. |
| | + | |
| | + | Oh, uh, anyways, the contest. Content was sturctured fine. Some icon pizzazz and integration with other pages could be added, but again, the Wiki currently operates with expectation that there isn't a data dump item ID repository available. So to have that integrated for some rats but not others would be odd. And here I go again about the greater Wiki... |
| | + | |
| | + | Lacking a summary for a page creation is understandable. No out-of-wiki communications that I am aware of. |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
| Line 1,929: |
Line 1,938: |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Drebin's comments|width= 100%| |
| − | This is the place for your comments
| + | So, I will say that Gabriel did put out a very nice infographic of the WHC's bookmarking scheme. If that had been added to the Wiki during the contest period, I'd say that he would have ''easily'' have been an excellence candidate, in my mind. |
| − | Thank you for being a judge :)
| + | |
| | + | But it wasn't. So going off of what was added during the contest period, having the probe scanners is a very nice addition! A cool thing to see! Edit summary was concise. No wiki-related communication I could immediately find. |
| | }} | | }} |
| | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| | | | style="vertical-align: top;" | {{CollapseBox|Menelmir's comments|width= 100%| |
